M: American diplomats were telling the truth. Many private cables confirm the outlines of what U.S. diplomats have said in public. Consider corruption in Afghanistan. Americans have said it's a problem. Although the leaks do add to our understanding of that problem, as NPR's Jackie Northam reports.
JACKIE NORTHAM: Patrick Cronin, a senior advisor at the Center for a New American Security, says much of the information was already known, but there's more to be gleaned from the cables.
PATRICK CRONIN: You can find new insights into our own conduct of this war, our own conduct of our diplomacy. Even though there's nothing new, there are new vivid details about corruption, about the challenge that we face, really, toward trying to achieve a political objective and an outcome.
NORTHAM: And while much of this information has come out in congressional hearings or through the media, Cronin says it makes a difference to see the concerns and complaints written down on paper.
CRONIN: To see something in print makes a difference. It does give it more impact. To see the actual cable arrests your mind and says, my goodness, this is serious.
NORTHAM: One cable talks about the brother of a revered military commander, Ahmed Shah Massoud, who was killed by suspected al-Qaida militants. The brother, Ahmed Zia Massoud, is a politician with a salary of a few hundred dollars a month. The diplomatic cable says last year he was caught carrying $50 million on arrival in Dubai. Massoud denies the allegation.
AHMED ZIA MASSOUD: (Through translator) How one person can carry $50 million - where is the proof of this $50 million? I am ready to answer anywhere I am required. This is completely wrong and incorrect.
NORTHAM: Christine Fair with Georgetown University's Peace and Security Studies Program says none of these criticisms will be new to Karzai.
CHRISTINE FAIR: It's easy to point the finger at Karzai because he is so deeply culpable of so many problems. But it really has to be remembered that this is a synergistic relationship and the way in which we have dealt with Karzai, local strongmen, to serve the purposes of our counterinsurgency, is quite frankly hypocritical at best.
NORTHAM: For example, Fair says look at the way the U.S. treats Karzai's brother, Ahmed Wali Karzai, who's head of the provincial council in Kandahar. Several cables focus on his alleged ties to Afghanistan's opium trade.
FAIR: It's one thing to be very clear that he is a part of an enormous drug-trafficking network that nets all sorts of proceeds that go into various pockets, but how about the reality that he's been on the CIA payroll?
NORTHAM: But the diplomatic cables are not meant to analyze or offer solutions, says Thomas Johnson, an Afghanistan expert at the Naval Postgraduate School. The cables are just raw data and observations, but when they're leaked like this, they can send out the wrong signal, says Johnson.
THOMAS JOHNSON: The average Afghan looks at us and says, why is it taking so long, and they've completely lost confidence in us. So many of the average Afghans will look at this and say, hey, you know, their perception is the United States just isn't doing enough. There's some truth in that, but there's a much bigger story, actually.
NORTHAM: Jackie Northam, NPR News, Washington.
: You hear some of the most thorough coverage of Afghanistan right here on MORNING EDITION from NPR News.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.