For Young Swiss Rebels, A Dark Chapter In History Until the 1980s, thousands of rebellious Swiss youths were locked up without trial. Officials called it "administrative detention." But in reality, the kids were put in prison or labor camps. Now, many victims are demanding accountability and compensation for damaged lives.
NPR logo

For Young Swiss Rebels, A Dark Chapter In History

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
For Young Swiss Rebels, A Dark Chapter In History

For Young Swiss Rebels, A Dark Chapter In History

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


This is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. I'm Audie Cornish.


And I'm Robert Siegel.

Switzerland has a reputation for being calm, well ordered and discreet. And for decades, the Swiss government was discreet about a dubious social policy. From the 1940s until the early 1980s, thousands of rebellious or disruptive adolescents were placed in what the authorities called administrative detention. The victims say they were held in adult prisons or labor camps without trial and they're now demanding compensation from the state.

NPR's Eric Westervelt reports.

ERIC WESTERVELT: In the late 1960s, Zurich-born Ursula Biondi was 16 years old when she ran away to Italy with her 20-something boyfriend after fighting with her parents. Biondi was pregnant when Italian authorities returned her against her will to Switzerland. Biondi's mother, in the meantime, had turned to local Swiss canton, or state authorities, for help. Seeing the girl as morally lax, local officials, upon her return, locked Biondi up in Hindelbank prison for women.

Ms. URSULA BIONDI: I didn't know it, that this was a jail, because I was never in front of a court, in front of a judge.

WESTERVELT: Biondi, several months pregnant, says she sometimes worked 10 hours a day in the prison laundry alongside convicted murderers, thieves and drug offenders. At night, she was locked in a cell. Biondi says, in some ways, the criminals had it better.

Ms. BIONDI: They knew when they would be released. We didn't know. They had more rights than we had. I never felt ashamed personally. I just had a terrible anger in me. And always the same question, what have they done to us?

WESTERVELT: Biondi's father, a construction worker, had to scrape to come up with the 7,000 francs for the so-called tuition fee in what Swiss authorities called an educational program for his promiscuous daughter. Prison officials told Biondi her baby would be put up for adoption. Her mother soon demanded her daughter's release and, after a year, Biondi was reunited with her infant son and released from jail.

Her tale is one of thousands suffered by Swiss youth subjected to so-called administrative detention. It was a practice started in the 1880s and lasted until the early 1980s. Now, after decades of silence, many victims today are demanding accountability and compensation for damaged lives.

Christopher Poeschmann paws through a homemade book of carefully preserved documents and letters. The papers are his proof.

Mr. CHRISTOPHER POESCHMANN: The people don't believe you. So you close your mouth.

WESTERVELT: The 50-year-old Swiss crane operator was abandoned as an infant and had a troubled childhood. In the mid-1970s, as a teenager, he went on the road, working carnivals and doing odd jobs across Europe. He ended up in Germany without papers. Deported back to Switzerland, local Swiss authorities deemed him a dangerous, work-shy gypsy.

Mr. POESCHMANN: They're thinking, this little tramp, and we want not this. You cannot be always traveling in the world and how you like. You must be learning working.

WESTERVELT: The camp was more like a prison chain gang. Poeschmann worked alongside criminals cutting trees on steep hillsides. It was incredibly dangerous work. He remembers frozen hands, horrible food and stuffing old newspapers into his ragged boots to try to keep his feet dry and warm. He says the labor camp bosses tried to break his will and his mind.

Mr. POESCHMANN: That you are so broken that you are never more a rebel, you know, a young rebel.

WESTERVELT: Eventually, Poeschmann made a run for it. He ended up in Marseille, France, and joined the French Foreign Legion. It was his ticket out. He was 17. In later life, he never told his wife and kids about the work camp. Now, he says he's done keeping his mouth shut. He says, tearing up, the authorities had a responsibility for helping young people, and instead they did this.

It's been nearly impossible for researchers to determine how many victims were involved because many official files, to this day, remain closed, while many older victims have died off. This barely known chapter of Swiss history was exposed recently by journalist Dominique Strebel with the Swiss magazine The Observer.

Strebel, author of the new book "Locked Away," says Swiss officials found a way to sideline rebellious teens while getting free labor out of them.

Mr. DOMINIQUE STREBEL (Swiss journalist and author): They didn't want to deal with the problems of these kids, and they had problems because their parents were divorced, for example, or they were poor and nobody really cared about these kids. And in the end, they put them in prisons because they said, you don't do well, you always run away. We shut them away and let the parents pay for it.

WESTERVELT: This fall, the Swiss justice minister apologized. Victims welcomed the symbolic gesture as long overdue, but said sorry was totally inadequate. Some now want compensation and the wider Swiss society to acknowledge its part in going along with the systemic abuse of young people.

Even today, many ordinary Swiss seem reluctant to acknowledge what happened. Victim Ursula Biondi says many people here simply assume she must have done something wrong to be put in Hindelbank prison. She says of her country, beware of places that appear too clean. There's always muck just below the surface.

Eric Westervelt, NPR News, Zurich.

Copyright © 2010 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.