Complications, Contradictions In A Fla. Swing County The biggest single issue for Florida nurse practitioner Sofia Martinez is her support of the DREAM Act. But she plans to vote for Republican Mitt Romney, who has said he would veto the measure. Her view might seem full of contradictions, but that's common among voters in Hillsborough County, as they consider complex issues.
NPR logo

Complications, Contradictions In A Fla. Swing County

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Complications, Contradictions In A Fla. Swing County

Complications, Contradictions In A Fla. Swing County

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Now, let's meet one person who will be voting this fall.


Sofia Martinez was a kid when she began what you could call her life on the road.

SOFIA MARTINEZ: I can remember my dad used to work in a factory in Toledo, Ohio, lost his job. And then that's when we started becoming a migrant family. So I was around nine years old, in the third grade.

INSKEEP: She still remembers the crops. She still remembers the seasons of a life lived North and South. She'd begin the school year in Ohio.

MARTINEZ: And right around October, November, we would get pulled out of school, come down here to Florida and start with orange groves, grapefruit, and then strawberry and then tomatoes, and then right around April or May, head back up to Ohio to do the whole thing all over again.

INSKEEP: Now that she's grown up, Martinez has settled down. She got her education, and has a job in Plant City, Florida. That town is part of Hillsborough County, which we're visiting all week, for our series First and Main.

We're meeting voters where they live, listening to them think, and letting them open a door into their lives.


INSKEEP: This particular door opens to an exam room, in a pediatrics clinic, part of a community health chain called SunCoast. Martinez is a nurse practitioner here. Many patients come from migrant families, like the woman who brought a toddler with a dry cough.

MARTINEZ: (Spanish spoken)

INSKEEP: Martinez is Mexican-American. She was born in the USA, but many of her patients were not. Another of her patients on the morning we visited was a three-day-old baby whose father had just been deported.

MARTINEZ: Sad. Common, very common.

INSKEEP: And her experience leads her to support the DREAM Act. That proposal would make it easier for children brought to this country illegally to become citizens.

MARTINEZ: Those students grow up here, maybe be here all their life, they've ever even know or heard or remember Mexico or wherever they're from, and they can't go to college. They can't get a drivers license. They can't - you know, and the DREAM Act, I hope, one day won't be a dream, and a lot of these kids can do what I did and make something of themselves.

INSKEEP: President Obama's administration has said it will stop deporting many young people, whether the DREAM Act is passed or not.

Mitt Romney has spoken of vetoing the DREAM Act, and of pushing illegal immigrants to, quote, "self-deport." But that issue will not determine how Martinez votes.

Mitt Romney, President Obama. What are you thinking?

MARTINEZ: From my core values, what my core values are, I will be voting Republican.

INSKEEP: She says that party matches her values. Martinez was raised Catholic, is now Baptist, and is the mother of two daughters.

MARTINEZ: Sometimes the stories that come back from school - even the teacher isn't giving my child a good moral, you know, compass. The desensitization of our children to violence and sex, it's hard. And hopefully, public school won't get any worse than it already is.

INSKEEP: One of Martinez's co-workers joined our conversation. She said Romney is closer to what she call's God's values, and mentioned President Obama's support for gay marriage. To which Martinez adds...

MARTINEZ: I don't hate Obama by any means. You know, he has done an OK job. I don't think he's done a terrible job. I don't think he's, you know, put our country in the sewer. But for me, I mean, I would think that if the country got back to some basic core values, maybe we'd all do a lot better.

INSKEEP: Do you ever say this to friends, relatives who respond to you, the Democrats favor the DREAM Act? The Democrats speak up for immigrants? Republicans have been pushing for tougher policies on immigrants? Have you had people say that to you?

MARTINEZ: Unfortunately, I don't think either party makes the best advocacy for migrants or farm workers. The Democrats have touted a lot about their DREAM Act and, you know, maybe doing a lot of promises. But still, the DREAM Act has been going on for how long, and it still hasn't been in effect.

INSKEEP: Sofia Martinez serves as a reminder about the huge and growing Hispanic vote in this country. While the group leans Democratic, it's not monolithic. And while analysts expect President Obama to win Hispanics, the question is by how much. The margin matters in a closely divided state like Florida.

When it comes time to count the votes in Hillsborough County, Romney can rely on Sofia Martinez. But if he should campaign here, he should not rely on her to stay quiet about that one issue that touches her life.

This is a really important county. They're going to be here a lot.

MARTINEZ: I hope they come through the door. That would be awesome.

INSKEEP: Mm-hmm. If had an opportunity, you know, if Obama walked in the door, if Romney walked in the door, is there some really specific question from...

MARTINEZ: Sign the DREAM Act. That's what I would say. Sign the DREAM Act.

INSKEEP: You've got a one-point agenda and that's...

MARTINEZ: That's it.


MARTINEZ: I want him to sign the DREAM Act. If they only do one thing, sign that DREAM Act.

INSKEEP: Now, if her view seems full of contradictions, that is common among many voters, as they consider many issues in Hillsborough County. And maybe that's understandable.

Florida voters, like voters everywhere, are responding to life in a complicated nation. It was, after all, the American poet Walt Whitman who wrote: Very well, then, I contradict myself. I am large. I contain multitudes.

It's only at election time that multitudes are asked to choose between parties that enforce rigid visions of a small and divided world.


INSKEEP: Tomorrow, we'll meet a stay-at-home mom in a Tampa neighborhood adjusting to the new normal.

Copyright © 2012 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.