TV Review - 'Bates Motel' and 'Top Of The Lake' Jane Campion directs a new Sundance Channel miniseries, Top of the Lake, about a young New Zealand detective played by Mad Men's Elisabeth Moss. Meanwhile, producers from Lost and Friday Night Lights team up to create a prequel to Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho, called Bates Motel.
NPR logo

Two New TV Dramas Look Below The Surface

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Two New TV Dramas Look Below The Surface

Two New TV Dramas Look Below The Surface

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Two new dramas premiered tonight on TV, one from the creator of the movie "The Piano" and the other from producers whose credits include "Lost," and "Friday Night Lights." Our TV critic David Bianculli has this review.

DAVID BIANCULLI, BYLINE: "Top of the Lake," a new seven-part miniseries premiering tonight on the Sundance Channel, is co-created and co-directed by Jane Campion, who teamed with Holly Hunter 20 years ago on the movie "The Piano." Hunter is back for this new project, playing a mysterious New Agey guru of sorts. She's started a small commune for emotionally damaged women, on a remote strip of land in New Zealand.

That story could have been at the center of "Top of the Lake," but it isn't. It's more like a running subplot, just like the story that opens the drama - the tale of a 12-year-old girl named Tui who is found walking into a frigid lake, presumably to take her own life.

She's taken to the authorities, who can't get any details out of her. So they call in a visiting female detective who used to be a local. And "Top of the Lake," especially after the young girl vanishes, turns out to be mostly about that detective.

And that's a good thing, because the detective, Robin, is played by Elisabeth Moss, who plays Peggy on "Mad Men." No matter how good you think she is on "Mad Men," I suspect you'll be unprepared for her complicated performance here - and not only because she sports an effective New Zealand accent, but because her character is so rough, so raw and so constantly conflicted.

The pace of "Top of the Lake" is so deliberate and the atmosphere so oppressive, that its overall tone is close to the moodiness of the AMC series "The Killing." The beautiful but foreboding setting is a strong character here - but the strongest, in addition to the determined women played by Hunter and Moss, is Tui's father, Matt Mitcham, a local backwoods drug lord played by Peter Mullan.

Matt Mitcham is like a Kiwi version of Al Swearengen from "Deadwood" - charismatic and deadly all at the same time. Robin gets a taste of this when she first meets Mitcham. She's looking into the death of a local real estate agent named Bob Platt, and visits Mitcham's fortress-like property. He's around back with a dog that's tied to a post and a shotgun within reach. Within a minute of her arrival, he fires the gun - killing the dog, and freaking out Robin.


PETER MULLAN: (as Matt) You like dogs?

ELISABETH MOSS: (as Robin) Yes.

MULLAN: (as Matt) Would you like an orphan one?

MOSS: (as Robin) No thanks.

MULLAN: (as Matt) Your dilemma. It's Bob Platt's dog. I was hoping she would settle in. She's already bit my eye dog and she's riled up the others.

MOSS: (as Robin) Why have you got Platt's dog?

MULLAN: (as Matt) He drowned. Didn't you hear? She was hungry so I took her in. No dog should go hungry. It's not right.

MOSS: (as Robin) You're going to shoot her?

MULLAN: (as Matt) If you don't want her.

MOSS: (as Robin) Wasn't there anyone else who could've taken her? How about Platt's wife?

MULLAN: (as Matt) Platt didn't have a wife. The truth is, he was a dumb prick. Nobody liked him. Nobody liked his dog either, except me.

BIANCULLI: Mitcham frightens Robin, but he doesn't stop her. The biggest mystery in "Top of the Lake," it turns out, is what drives Robin - her own demons and hidden secrets, and why she connects so strongly with the missing girl. It's less a mystery than a character study - and despite the show's title, "Top of the Lake," all the rewards in this miniseries lie way beneath the surface.

Another TV drama premiering tonight, A&E's "Bates Motel," is primarily a character study as well - but this time we already know the character. He's Norman Bates, the creepy killer from "Psycho" with a fixation with his late mother. "Bates Motel" is a prequel to "Psycho," showing Norman in his formative high school years. His mother is very much alive - and her name is Norma

MOSS: This new look at "Psycho" comes from two very respected TV executive producers: Carlton Cuse from "Lost" and Kerry Ehrin, a writer-producer on "Boston Legal," "Friday Night Lights," and "Parenthood." Given that pedigree, you hope "Bates Motel" will work.

BIANCULLI: But it begins clumsily, with a creative choice that could have doomed it from the start: Even though it's a prequel to the 1960 movie, "Bates Motel" ignores that timeline and is set in the present. Logically, that doesn't make any sense.

But dramatically, it allows the writers to surround young Norman with all sorts of confusing and conflicting stimuli, from iPods to flirtatious young coeds. Imagine young Norman Bates let loose on one of those CW teen dramas and that's pretty much what you've got here.

Except, in the two lead actors, you've got something better. Freddie Highmore from "Finding Neverland" plays Norman, and Vera Farmiga, who starred opposite George Clooney "Up in the Air," is Norma. In one scene from the pilot, they're out rowing on the local lake, and the way they're talking, it could almost be a date. But they're mother and son - oh, and they're out there in the middle of the night, about to dump a body into the water.


VERA FARMIGA: (as Norma) You're too good for me. I am the worst mother in the world.

FREDDIE HIGHMORE: (as Norman) Mother.

FARMIGA: (as Norma) Look at what we're doing, Norman. And you deserve so much better. You know, when you were born it was like God gave me a second chance. And all I ever wanted was for life to be beautiful for you. And look at it. Look at what your life has been. I mean, what good am I doing you?

HIGHMORE: (as Norman) Mom, you're everything. Everything to me. And I don't ever want to live in a world without you.

BIANCULLI: What finally won me over about "Bates Motel" was when it started showing us life from Norman's point of view, including brief glimpses of his often disturbing fantasies. Everywhere he turns, Norman seems to be surrounded by tempting women and threatening men. So for escape, and release, he turns inward. It's not a happy place - but on a medium that's already given us a serial killer as protagonist in "Dexter," it's a natural progression.

GROSS: David Bianculli is founder and editor of the website TV Worth Watching and he teaches TV and film history at Rowan University in New Jersey.


GROSS: You can download podcasts of our show on our website And you can follow us on Twitter at nprfreshair and on Tumblr at

Copyright © 2013 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.