What Is The Role Of Jails In Treating The Mentally Ill? The United States incarcerates hundreds of thousands of inmates with mental health needs. Prisons and jails are trying to provide support, but incarceration is far from therapeutic.
NPR logo

What Is The Role Of Jails In Treating The Mentally Ill?

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/222822452/222820580" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
What Is The Role Of Jails In Treating The Mentally Ill?

What Is The Role Of Jails In Treating The Mentally Ill?

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/222822452/222820580" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


This is WEEKENDS on ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. I'm Jacki Lyden.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: Slider one, please.


LYDEN: The metal doors slide open at the Twin Towers Correctional Facility in downtown Los Angeles. And the concrete towers do loom over the largest municipal jail system in the United States.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #3: ...A-15, he's in nine.

LYDEN: We watch as four men enter, handcuffed, with a police escort. They're coming in from court. The sheriff's deputies assign them cells. For the duration of their sentences, this is home.



UNIDENTIFIED MAN #4: All right. Let's go, man.

LYDEN: These men are wearing bright blue pants and neon yellow shirts, which sets them apart. Lieutenant Joseph Badali is a supervisor with the sheriff's department.

LIEUTENANT JOSEPH BADALI: Here within Twin Towers, we house approximately 3,900 inmates. A majority of those inmates are deemed mentally ill.

LYDEN: In this regard, L.A. County Jail is not unique - far from it. And that's our cover story today: the mentally ill, patients and prisoners.


LYDEN: Every year, an estimated 2.1 million people are booked into local jails with a serious mental disorder, often for short stays. Once, huge day hospitals housed the mentally ill. When they closed in the 1970s, community-based care was supposed to step in. But instead, the mentally ill were released to the streets, where they often got into trouble. Jails have to take mentally ill offenders in, but they can't force medication.

SARA HOUGH: It's so important that you take your medication and you comply with treatment, because if you don't, you're going to come back here, and we don't want you to come back here.



LYDEN: Psychiatrist Sara Hough is talking with an inmate through glass. She's chosen to wear a yellow blouse and blue capris today, matching the clothing of the inmates she calls her clients. [POST-BROADCAST CORRECTION: In the audio of this story, as in a previous Web version, we refer to Sara Hough as a psychiatrist. In fact, she is a psychologist. Also, in 2013 she was head of the Department of Mental Health at the Twin Towers Correctional Facility, not the head of clinical psychiatry.]


HOUGH: All right. It's good to see you smiling. I'm so happy for you, but keep up the good work...

LYDEN: Because of its size, the L.A. County Jail is the country's largest mental institution. And Hough has held a job here for 15 years. She's now the head of clinical psychiatry.

The incarceration of mentally ill people costs taxpayers many millions of dollars, experts say far more than it costs to treat them in the community. Here in Tower One, a sheriff's deputy is leading group therapy.

UNIDENTIFIED MAN #6: Being a good communicator takes practice. Everyone understand that?



LYDEN: In this pod of the jail, the inmates aren't manacled. They're not considered risky. In another area, the inmates sit handcuffed to a table, quietly watching "Iron Man 3." But two of these men are on suicide watch, and they wear only a heavy blue blanket Hough calls a suicide gown.

HOUGH: It's difficult to shred. It's difficult to manipulate so they can use it as a means of hurting themselves. So it provides greater security.

LYDEN: Ninety percent of the mentally ill at Twin Towers also have a substance abuse issue. For as long as they're here, they'll receive counseling.



LYDEN: The hospital within the prison opened in 1977, right around the height of deinstitutionalization, when mental hospitals were closing. Gabriel Rodriguez is a registered nurse and works in the unit.

GABRIEL RODRIGUEZ: Most of our patients that come up here are very fragile cases, very delicate. They're very ill. And they're refusing to take medications. They're not following treatment. They're not going to court.

LYDEN: That means the staff is watching some truly at-risk people here, as signs make evident. No sharps, no plastic eating utensils, no wristband, no pencil, no objects patient might use to scratch self.


LYDEN: There's a 25-year-old man rocking back and forth in his cell. The staff say he's developmentally disabled, mentally ill and sometimes violent. And he's been in and out of this jail multiple times. And the revolving door syndrome is, to say the least, frustrating for everyone. Again, Nurse Rodriguez.

RODRIGUEZ: I spoke to a family member today who says, you know, we're really burnt out. My brother, he comes off two weeks out of jail, he's doing fine, and then he stops doing medication, and he gets arrested.

LYDEN: Here in the in-patient hospital on the seventh floor, around 30 inmates get treatment. Jail officials say they wish they had many times that number of beds to cope with all the acute cases. I asked Dr. Sara Hough about this.

HOUGH: It just begs the whole question, are we not turning our prisoners into hospitals? In many ways, we are a hospital. What brought them into the system was an alleged crime, and we certainly at the Department of Health are not here to judge that. But while they're here and they suffer mental illness, we will provide care.

LYDEN: The county says it's trying to make the best of a tough situation. Columnist Steve Lopez calls it a crime.

STEVE LOPEZ: For some people, maybe it's better than being on the street. But that doesn't mean that a jail is a therapeutic environment, and that doesn't mean that this is good public policy, and it doesn't mean that anybody should find this acceptable.

LYDEN: Steve Lopez is a writer for the L.A. Times. He's put county mental health here on the national radar. A series of his columns about a homeless violinist with mental problem became a film. Lopez says it's simple: Jail is no place for treatment. And research backs that up. The list of potential harm to the already sick is a long one. According to the Justice Department, people with psychological disorders are much more likely to be sexually victimized by fellow inmates, and the sheer size of this population makes it a target.

There are multiple federal investigations of abuse in the county jail system, and that includes Twin Towers, though it's another jail, the Men's Central Jail, which has attracted notoriety.

In response to the federal investigation, the L.A. County Department of Mental Health told NPR: We look forward to continuing collaboration and assessing and improving our services. Steve Lopez says that once treated, stabilized and released to the outside world, there are no guarantees for the mentally ill population.

LOPEZ: OK. What happens to people when they've done their time and they're dismissed? What then? Well, the sad news is that the majority of them are turned out onto the streets with no linkage to any kind of community-based treatment center. And this is a population that needs regular management. You know, that jail is not far from Skid Row. And somebody who comes out can take a short walk and end up, you know, in an outdoor drug market and fall immediately back into the same patterns that got them into jail in the first place.

LYDEN: We met one man who's done just that many times.

JAMES PUNTAR: My name is James Puntar.

LYDEN: James Puntar is 53. He grew up in Southern California and says he started doing drugs when he was just 9 years old. His addictions only got worse.

PUNTAR: By junior high school, I was eating acid. And by high school, I was smoking PCP. And then...

LYDEN: Puntar is the first person to admit he's made a lot of bad choices with his life. For many years, he lived on the streets, homeless. He's been arrested for drunk driving and petty theft. He made money dealing drugs. He's been in Twin Towers. Puntar also has chronic mental illness and a hodgepodge of diagnoses.

PUNTAR: Schizophrenia, depression, anxiety, mood swings, bipolar. I mean, I've seen a lot of doctors.

LYDEN: Inside jail, Puntar says he got help - medications and therapy. But it can be costly or difficult or all but impossible to stay on a med schedule unsupervised. And Puntar told us he soon abused drugs again outside. They did not quiet his mind.

PUNTAR: I'd be in the store, and I'd have money, and I'd hear people saying, he's in the bathroom, let's rob him. And I would barricade myself into the bathroom in the store. And the manager's out there - come out of there. It's the manager. And I'm like, how do I know it's the manager?

LYDEN: There were times when he couldn't find somewhere warm to sleep or the money to eat. And in those moments, he said, he thought about going back to the one place he could always count on.

PUNTAR: I actually went to the store, and I said, what's like the lowest level offense that I could commit to go to jail? And then I could, you know, have some food and get my head back together.

LYDEN: James Puntar says he now has two years sober. A nonprofit group called the Integrated Recovery Network provides him with housing and mental health services. And he's working towards becoming an addiction counselor. But he is 53 years old, and he says he's taking life one day at a time.

PUNTAR: People my age, they got jobs they've retired from, they've got houses, they've got kids who are grown and married, you know? Me, I got nothing. I ain't never had a wife, never had kids. You know, I was married to drugs, and my home that I had built for myself was prison. It was always there. It's there right now.

DR. LINDA TEPLIN: We have to remember that it is not the jail's choice to take these people.

LYDEN: Dr. Linda Teplin is professor of psychiatry at Northwestern University. She has researched incarceration and mental illness for more than three decades. Perhaps, she suggests, it's the jails that have come the furthest in that time.

TEPLIN: Jails have been very good nationwide now about recognizing the need to screen for severe mental disorder and also to provide treatment. This is certainly not a cheaper system, but it is easier to fund the building of new correctional facilities than it is to obtain funds to provide mental health care in the community.

LYDEN: What role would you say that stigma plays in these decisions?

TEPLIN: People with severe mental illnesses on the street are not the poster child for people with mental disorders. They may engage in bizarre behavior - walking down the middle of the street on a hot July night wearing a ski jacket. Many people are afraid of persons with severe mental illnesses who exhibit these symptoms. They're not a sympathetic group.

LYDEN: People throughout the system have acknowledged for a long time that it's not working properly. What would it take for this policy to change?

TEPLIN: If we had a major public figure take leadership in this area, perhaps because of an ill family member, I think that would do a lot to alert the public's sensitivity to the plight of people with severe mental illnesses being arrested instead of treated.

LYDEN: There are signs of change. Many cities have added training for police and created mental health courts that divert people from jail. But day centers and community centers around the country are often struggling, trying to raise funds to improve services and acceptance. The new Obama health care law may improve access to mental health care. That's certainly the hope. But L.A. County is also exploring another option: building a new jail at a cost of more than $1 billion. It would have one chief purpose: housing and caring for inmates who are mentally ill.


LYDEN: This is NPR News.

Copyright © 2013 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.