A Night At The Rock: Former Alcatraz Inmate Journeys Back After more than 50 years, Bill Baker returns to the island in an effort to analyze his life.
NPR logo

A Night At The Rock: Former Alcatraz Inmate Journeys Back

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/231536397/234234148" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
A Night At The Rock: Former Alcatraz Inmate Journeys Back

A Night At The Rock: Former Alcatraz Inmate Journeys Back

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/231536397/234234148" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


This is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED, from NPR News. I'm Melissa Block.

Alcatraz, the notorious prison off the coast of San Francisco, closed 50 years ago. For almost three decades, it housed some of the nation's worst criminals. Today, it's a museum. Earlier this year, the National Park Service granted one former inmate special permission to spend the night in his old cell.

His name is Bill Baker. He was 24 when he was transferred to The Rock. Today, he's 80. NPR's Laura Sullivan went with him. And a word of caution: This story contains some strong language.

LAURA SULLIVAN, BYLINE: Bill Baker has spent a lot of his life in and out of federal prison, almost always for the same thing: cashing fraudulent checks. By 1957, he was already an accomplished thief, serving time in Leavenworth prison. He's never been a violent criminal, and he wasn't then. So it came as a great shock when officials from the Federal Bureau of Prisons told him they were transferring him to Alcatraz.

See, there was something else about Bill Baker - he loved escaping from prison, and prison officials had had enough. So on a foggy January morning, he boarded a boat to a prison built on an island.


SULLIVAN: He never thought he would do it again half a century later voluntarily, with tourists.

BILL BAKER: I wasn't very happy the last time I was on a boat over here. We were all cuffed up and chained. And we couldn't see shore from any direction because of the fog. And, you know, we didn't know where we were.

SULLIVAN: The boat docked, and we funnel inside the prison, into the same dark, damp hallway Bill Baker walked through as an inmate - except instead of a shower room, the hallway now ends in a gift shop.

BAKER: I mean, they've got all kinds of souvenirs here, don't they.

SULLIVAN: At the front of the gift shop, Baker sees a former Alcatraz prison guard named Pat Mahoney, signing books at the author's desk with his wife. They quickly sounded like old friends.


PAT MAHONEY: You remember old Buppy Johnson(ph)?

BAKER: Yes, he always had a good story. And then Blackie Oddette(ph) that worked our mess hall.

MAHONEY: Oh yeah, Blackie Oddette.

BAKER: Blackie was something else.


BAKER: Remember Punchy Bailey(ph)?


BAKER: He worked with you, didn't he?

MAHONEY: I think so, yeah.

BAKER: There's about two of us left. The rest are all - got Alzheimer's and (unintelligible) what the hell is what.


SULLIVAN: Do you ever think 60 years ago that the two of you were going to be standing over the...

BAKER: Never.


SULLIVAN: ...the book table at the Alcatraz gift shop?

BAKER: Not in my wildest dreams.


SULLIVAN: We make our way up the stairs to the place Baker has come to see: the cell block.

BAKER: OK, by golly. Here we are.

SULLIVAN: It's three tiers of faded yellow and green cells with peeling paint and rusting bars. Baker is no longer talking. He's just looking at the cells.

Is it hard to be back here?

BAKER: Don't really know. I haven't analyzed that part of it yet. One of the reasons I'm staying overnight here is so that I can maybe figure some things out.

SULLIVAN: And just like that, Baker starts walking, heading down one corridor to another, like he was just here yesterday.

BAKER: I want to go around the other side close to (unintelligible) once were.

SULLIVAN: We head to what was one of Baker's favorite places, the prison rec yard.

BAKER: This was the ball field right here - the bases and everything. And people would walk the yard, back and forth there.

SULLIVAN: He stops in front of a small patch of dirt. And he says he once planted a tree right here. He pulled it up by its roots one day outside the workshop. And he says he watered it every day, for weeks.

Was it growing?

BAKER: It was taking to the dirt, yeah. I was going to have me a shade tree...


BAKER: ...when it was over.


SULLIVAN: But one day, all that watering caught the eye of a guard.

BAKER: He watched me a lot because he hated me. And he came over and said: What are you watering these weeds for? They don't need watering. I said oh, it's just something to do. You know, I mean...

SULLIVAN: The next day, he went to water his tree. All the weeds, and his tree, were gone.

BAKER: Oh, I was mad.


BAKER: You know, I was madder than hell. It was something that was growing, you know. It was life.


SULLIVAN: As a helicopter carrying tourists buzzed overhead, Bill Baker stood in the prison yard and began to tremble.

BAKER: Son of a bitch... (Crying)

SULLIVAN: Baker fell against the prison wall and cried. We sat there, out in the concrete yard, watching the sailboats pass under the Golden Gate Bridge. Baker told me he was born during the Great Depression in Kentucky. When he was 3, his mother said she couldn't afford to keep him, and he bounced around with relatives. At 16, he was on his own.

After a while, we headed back inside. The tourists were all gone. There were just a few rangers left, locking doors.

Sure is empty right now.

BAKER: Yes. It's weird, too. It's getting weirder by the minute.


SULLIVAN: I agree with you.

BAKER: Quiet. Holy smoke, reckon there really is ghosts in here?

SULLIVAN: Well, I don't know. I guess we'll find out.

We grabbed our sleeping bags and headed up to the cells.

How old do you think these beds are?

BAKER: I don't know - pretty old. I'll tell you something, that's probably a better mattress than we had.

SULLIVAN: This is a better mattress than what you had, 'cause these mattresses look like they're about a half a century old.


BAKER: Yeah.

SULLIVAN: We sat in Baker's old cell, barely big enough to hold the both of us.

What did you do in here all day?

BAKER: Very little. (Laughter) You know, can you imagine - 24 hours a day?

SULLIVAN: He was quiet for a minute.

BAKER: Well, see, I know I'm leaving here tomorrow. (Laughter) You know, I'm a short-timer. I can count the hours down now.

SULLIVAN: It's interesting because that thought has not even crossed my mind - that I would stay here.

BAKER: Yeah, you wouldn't even think to think that.


SULLIVAN: We wandered around the prison late into the night, walking the deserted tiers and darkened hallways. We browsed the empty gift shop; and we checked out the warden's office, which Baker had never seen. We never saw any ghosts.

Sometime around 1 in the morning, we came back to his cell. Park rangers had left him his prison file. They found it in the archives.

BAKER: (Laughter) This is funny to read: Not in his cell during count, visiting another inmate's cell, and kicked a bowl of food. (Laughter) That's just so funny.


BAKER: (Reading) He apologized for his behavior.

I don't think that's true. I don't remember ever apologizing for my behavior.

SULLIVAN: Why do you think you wanted to come back here?

BAKER: I don't know, you know? I just wonder if I can confront that crazy kid in this cell: You stupid son of a bitch, what's wrong with you? (Laughter) But it ain't that I don't understand a little bit, you know. I still like a little excitement.

SULLIVAN: Do you think if you could do it over, would you live a different life?

BAKER: No. If I - you know, if I could go back and have my same brain as it is right now in the body of a young kid, I would do it entirely different. But I know without a doubt that if I still had the brain of that kid, that you couldn't tell me nothing.

SULLIVAN: We tried to sleep on the rusty metal beds that so many others had slept on before. But neither of us could.


SULLIVAN: The next morning, at the crack of dawn, thousands of birds woke up.


SULLIVAN: Baker wasn't in his cell. But it wasn't hard to guess where an ex-convict would go if he woke up again in prison.

BAKER: (Laughter) Good morning.

SULLIVAN: Morning. I thought I might find you out here.

BAKER: Yeah, I've been out here since 5:30.

SULLIVAN: Were the birds this loud when you were here?

BAKER: No, they weren't. There weren't this many. I guess they figure it's theirs now.

SULLIVAN: Are you happy to give the island back over to them?

BAKER: You know what? I feel like I own part of this island. (Laughter) I don't know whether that's a good thing or not, but I do. I have squatter's rights, or something. You know, it's part mine.


SULLIVAN: Bill Baker sat on a bench in the morning fog, on an empty island in the middle of the San Francisco Bay. No longer an inmate, not quite a tourist.

Laura Sullivan. NPR News.


Copyright © 2013 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.