The Common Core Curriculum Void : NPR Ed States and school districts are struggling to navigate the flood of new materials claiming to be Common Core-aligned.
NPR logo

The Common Core Curriculum Void

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
The Common Core Curriculum Void

The Common Core Curriculum Void

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


We appreciate that you're spending time listening to us this morning on your public radio station. And just a reminder, you can follow us throughout the day on the radio, online and on social media. MORNING EDITION has a Facebook page. We are also on Twitter @MorningEdition, @NPRinskeep and @nprGreene. You're listening to MORNING EDITION from NPR News.


America's school boards are sprinting. Forty-four states in the District of Columbia have adopted the Common Core State Standards. And that means new learning benchmarks for the vast majority of the nation's young students - millions of kids from kindergarten through high school.

For many, the Core will feel tougher than what they're used to. It's a shift in education meant to better prepare kids for college and careers and the global economy. But new standards require lots of other changes to textbooks, to lesson plans, to homework assignments. And curriculum and materials are needed to teach that. Here's the problem - much of it just isn't ready. NPR's Cory Turner explains.

CORY TURNER, BYLINE: First, let me be clear. Standards are not curriculum. Standards are goals we set for kids. For example, one Common Core math standard says fifth graders should be able to use place value understanding to round decimals to any place.

Now, curriculum is what teachers do every day in the classroom to achieve that goal. They're different. But if you change standards, you've got to change curriculum, too. And that's the challenge right now with the Common Core.

JAY DISKEY: There's been no time in American history where this number of school districts wanted to swap out all their reading and math materials in all grades for new things.

TURNER: That's Jay Diskey with the Association of American Publishers. And this race to update and upgrade all of that stuff - it ends next year when all those millions of kids take their first Common Core test, a test with consequences. Kate Gerson is a senior fellow with the Region's Research Fund in New York.

KATE GERSON: We can no longer just pick something up and hand it to teachers and say go with it.

TURNER: So how did we get here? If states adopted the Core in 2010, why do some teachers still not have good teaching materials? Well, here's a quick history lesson. Back then, educational publishers, big and small, established and new, they saw an opportunity in the Core.

ALISSA PELTZMAN: The marketplace was flooded.

TURNER: That's Alissa Peltzman at Achieve, which helped develop the Core Standards. She says districts and schools were inundated with sample books - some new, some revised. Buy this, publishers said, often claiming it was aligned to the new standards.

PELTZMAN: If you put yourself in the place of an educator, a district administrator, someone responsible for making decisions about material, it's really hard to step back and know which materials really are high-quality and which materials are going to lead to increases in student achievement.

AMBER NORTHERN: I think anybody you'll talk to say it was a disgrace.

TURNER: Amber Northern is the Vice President for Research at the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, a conservative think tank that supports the Common Core.

NORTHERN: Some of this stuff is kind of snake oil salesman. You know, you - developing good materials takes time. And I don't think they trusted, when these materials came out, that there were Common Core aligned, despite the sticker.

TURNER: Despite the sticker. See, at the center of this story is a little gold sticker or stamp - or so it was described to me.

ROBERT HALL: Everything that I look at has a sticker on it that says aligned with the Common Core.

GERSON: That golden sticker does not necessarily represent real rigor.

PELTZMAN: There were shiny stickers being placed on materials saying these materials are high-quality and aligned. And it didn't take long to realize that that wasn't necessarily the case.

TURNER: Again, that was Alissa Peltzman at Achieve, Kate Gerson in New York and Robert Hall, Associate State Superintendent of Schools in West Virginia. They all tell the same story. When publishers tried to cash in on the Core, many of their books had these stickers on them, gold, often with the words Common Core in big letters.

The message to schools was this will help your teachers teach the Core. Here's the problem, says Amber Northern.

NORTHERN: That sticker appeared quickly- right? - after the adoption. So there's no way that they could have gone back and actually re-evaluated, re-assessed their materials and truly made a good faith effort to align those materials that quickly. It just was simply impossible.

TURNER: How bad were they?

So I'm standing in a resource slash storage room in Erickson Hall, which is the big Department of Education building on the campus of Michigan State University. I am 6 foot 5, and the shelves go above my head. And, on either side are shelves full of math textbooks.

I have a pen in my hand. This is how many books we're talking about - (sound of tapping) I'm running it across the spines. This is the domain of Professor William Schmidt. It's a little dark like a bear's cave. Only, instead of bones everywhere, there are math books on shelves, on tables, rising from the floor like stalagmites - from the floor all the way up.

And then, they go way up. I got to reach there. OK.

Schmidt runs Michigan State's Center for the Study of Curriculum. And his team has analyzed some 700 math textbooks, many with that gold stamp, to see just how well they line up with the Common Core standards. He says he'll often review a book that's chock full of material that has nothing to do with the Core.

WILLIAM SCHMIDT: Maybe as much as half or more of the book. And so in effect, if they follow the book from page one to page whatever, they're going to be led astray, and they're not going to cover the central material

TURNER: Of the 700-plus books that you reviewed for Core alignment, how many of them passed your test, shall we say?

SCHMIDT: If I were to say that they completely lineup - they're just straight on to the Common Core - virtually none of them.

TURNER: Professor Schmidt says his team has reviewed several brand new textbooks and they're much better. But the landscape in general? Still pretty bad. As messy as this sounds, it's easy to blame the Core. But that's like a hitter in baseball blaming his bat when he strikes out. This isn't about the standards. It's about how they've been implemented.

Some critics compare it to the botched rollout of Obamacare, hoping Obamacare hurts the president and Democrats in the coming midterms. But Common Core isn't a federal program. Washington's not on the hook here. States are. Most signed on, Democrats and Republicans alike, because they saw something necessary and ambitious. And implementing ambitious is never easy.

MARY CULLINANE: We should not be surprised that this is hard. But that doesn't mean we should walk away from it.

TURNER: Mary Cullinane is the chief content officer for Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, one of the big educational publishers. She says the problem isn't that publishers were just looking to cash in. The problem is that building good textbooks takes time.

CULLINANE: This isn't like building a song for 99 cents and then you put it out there and if somebody doesn't like it, they just don't listen to it anymore. Teachers are being held accountable. Kids are being held accountable. Communities are being held accountable.

TURNER: This time next year, kids across the country will take a new generation of standardized tests. And in many cases, students, teachers and schools will be judged on the results. These tests, everyone promises, will be aligned to the Common Core. The same cannot be said for the tools teachers and kids have prepare for them. Cory Turner, NPR News, Washington.

INSKEEP: Now, this afternoon on All Things Considered, Cory reports that teachers, schools and even some entire states are banding together to build their own classroom materials from scratch. This is NPR News.

Copyright © 2014 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.