In Los Angeles, Piecing Together The Numbers On Police Shootings Reliable data has been missing from the national debate. That's changing. An analysis by NPR member station KPCC found that from 2010 to 2014, 375 people were shot — and no officers were prosecuted.
NPR logo

In Los Angeles, Piecing Together The Numbers On Police Shootings

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/455502419/455510084" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
In Los Angeles, Piecing Together The Numbers On Police Shootings

In Los Angeles, Piecing Together The Numbers On Police Shootings

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/455502419/455510084" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

KELLY MCEVERS, HOST:

We're going to talk about something that has been missing from our national conversation about police shootings - reliable statistics. Across the country, there is no reliable government tally of officer-involved shootings. But that is starting to change. Here in Los Angeles, our member station KPCC obtained and reviewed records of on-duty police shootings for five years. They've put together a huge database that is the first real picture of police shootings in all of LA County. And KPCC's Frank Stoltze is with us here to talk about it.

And, Frank, we'll get to the findings in a minute. But first, can you just tell us about this project and the records that you reviewed?

FRANK STOLTZE, BYLINE: Yeah. Collecting data in LA County is especially challenging, with the LAPD, the sheriff's department, dozens of smaller police agencies, from Redondo Beach to Pasadena - policing an area with 10 million people. So KPCC embarked on an in-depth investigation focusing on collecting data from the one agency that reviews all police shootings, and that's the LA County District Attorney, which decides whether an officer's actions were lawful. The DA issues a letter on each and every shooting summarizing what happened and explaining why, in the DA's opinion, the shooting was legal.

MCEVERS: And Frank, you and your colleagues looked at cases from January 2010 to December 2014. What did you find?

STOLTZE: Well, we found at least 375 people were shot by on-duty police officers over that five-year period. About half of the shootings were fatal. And, not surprising, black people were fatally shot at a substantially higher rate, at nearly triple their proportion in the population. One of the biggest findings, though, was that a quarter of all people shot by police over this five-year period were unarmed.

MCEVERS: And we have a piece here about two of those unarmed men who were fatally shot by police by KPCC reporter Annie Gilbertson.

ANNIE GILBERTSON, BYLINE: Michael Nida had a big night planned. He and his wife, Naily, were going to Hollywood to celebrate his 32nd birthday.

JEAN THAXTON: They weren't gone from the house - I swear, they weren't gone from the house as soon as 15 minutes.

GILBERTSON: Jean Thaxton, who raised Nida, was babysitting for the couple. It felt like they had just said goodbye when the phone rang.

THAXTON: And I said hello. And Naley's on the phone, and she's saying, he's down, he's down, he's down on the ground. And I said, what do you mean, he's down? What are you talking about? She says, Michael - Michael, they shot him. I said, who shot him?

GILBERTSON: The police in Downey, a working-class suburb south of Los Angeles. It was around 9:30 on October 22, 2011.

A few weeks ago, friends and family gathered on a busy street to mark the anniversary of Nida's shooting.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: He was at the gas station here and he ran across the street.

GILBERTSON: According to the district attorney's summary reviewed by KPCC, Downey police were investigating an ATM robbery nearby, and they tried to question Nida but he ran. Officer Steven Gilley lost sight of Nida's hands. Gilley thought Nida was going for a gun, and shot.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: Came down through the driveway there, came out, stumbled here in the street right here - right here - and died.

GILBERTSON: He was unarmed. As soon as she got the phone call, Thaxton rushed to his side.

THAXTON: They had him in a stretcher and they were using that bagging thing for him to breathe.

GILBERTSON: She says she's still haunted by what she saw.

THAXTON: I saw the wound right here, right here, in his chest.

GILBERTSON: Officer Gilley, who's now Detective Gilley, declined to comment. So did the department. But LA County Sheriff Jim McDonnell says police across America are trained to watch a suspect's hands.

JIM MCDONNELL: They tell people to put their hands up, take your hands out of your pockets, put your hands up, let me see your hands. The hands are what kill you.

GILBERTSON: Officers have good reason to be cautious. KPCC's investigation found three-quarters of suspects were armed when officers shot at them. McDonnell says, what are cops supposed to think when the suspect doesn't put his hands up like he's told?

MCDONNELL: We're putting an officer, to represent the rest of us, in harm's way. What, reasonably, can we expect them to do when faced with similar circumstances?

GILBERTSON: The person who decides whether a shooting is reasonable - or, at least within the law - is District Attorney Jackie Lacey. Her office investigates every police shooting in Los Angeles County as a possible crime.

JACKIE LACEY: We understand the public's anger over what they perceive to be as unjustified shootings or killings, and we do our very, very best to shine light on whatever decision we make.

GILBERTSON: For the past 15 years, the decision has been the same every time. In case after case, prosecutors found on-duty officers shot legally because they feared for their lives or the lives of others. And it doesn't matter if that fear was real - or if the threat was imagined, like in the case of Dexter Luckett.

JANICE JOHNSON: I mean, I would accept if it was accidental...

GILBERTSON: That's Luckett's mom, Janice Johnson.

JOHNSON: ...But then they twist it and say his hand dropped, you know, like he was reaching for something.

GILBERTSON: Luckett was outside a party in Bellflower, another working-class town in South LA County. He was 23 years old, drinking beer with a friend, when the sheriff's deputies showed up.

BOBBY WATKINS: This is Tuesday night. It's a party. He's drinking beer.

GILBERTSON: Bobby Watkins is Luckett's stepdad.

WATKINS: So he was smoking a little reefer. What's the big deal?

GILBERTSON: Someone had called 911 saying they heard gunshots. Deputies told Luckett to put his hands on the hood of the patrol car. He put his beer on it instead. Sheriff's Deputy David Mailloux told investigators Luckett dropped his other hand behind him. Afraid Luckett was going to shoot him, Mailloux fired first, a single fatal shot to the chest. That's the official account from the DA. Mailloux wouldn't comment. Luckett's stepdad, Watkins, says there was no good reason to shoot.

WATKINS: It was not as if he was combative. He was not armed. He was not in the act of committing a crime.

GILBERTSON: Friends say maybe he was just pulling up his baggy pants. Watkins says the tragedy of it is that Luckett had big plans. He had enrolled in trade school just that morning.

WATKINS: He was happy about himself. He - happy that he achieved something.

GILBERTSON: He says Luckett wanted to be a border patrol agent.

MCEVERS: That's Annie Gilbertson of member station KPCC. KPCC reporter Frank Stoltze is with us, and we've got NPR's law enforcement correspondent, Martin Kaste, on the line.

And Martin, we're talking about 375 officer-involved shootings over five years and, yet, no officers were prosecuted. Is that normal, nationally?

MARTIN KASTE, BYLINE: That fits the pattern. In the last couple of decades, prosecutors have shown a lot of leeway to law enforcement officers for use of force. Basically the standard is, if that police officer reasonably believed to be in danger or thought the suspect posed a danger to somebody else, they're allowed to use force, even if it's deadly force.

MCEVERS: And looking at this KPCC database, you have to wonder, why isn't data like this available nationally?

KASTE: Because the U.S. is a lot like LA County. Policing is completely decentralized in this country. We're not even sure how many agencies we have. It's, roughly speaking, 17,000 or 18,000. When the feds ask for statistics like this, they're asking for it on a voluntary basis. And statistics aren't often forthcoming in a way that's reliable. What's interesting now is that the federal government is actually looking at media sources - things like this KPCC project - as a source of data in police-involved shootings.

MCEVERS: And, Frank Stoltze of KPCC, what's next with this project?

STOLTZE: Well, one thing is, we're going to look at disparities among police department. It appears the LA County Sheriff's Department, for example, shoots more unarmed people than the LAPD. Cops will say some of these are inevitable. But there's no industry standard. What's the lowest number of unarmed people you can get to?

MCEVERS: That's Frank Stoltze of member station KPCC.

Thanks so much.

STOLTZE: Thank you.

MCEVERS: And NPR's Martin Kaste.

Thank you Martin.

KASTE: You're welcome.

Copyright © 2015 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.