New Yorker's David Remnick On Obama's Post-Election Struggle For Optimism David Remnick, editor of The New Yorker talks about his interviews with President Obama in the days before and after the election.
NPR logo

New Yorker Editor David Remnick Describes Obama's Reactions To Election

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
New Yorker Editor David Remnick Describes Obama's Reactions To Election

New Yorker Editor David Remnick Describes Obama's Reactions To Election

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Here is a succinct analysis of last week's presidential vote - (reading) Trump understands the new ecosystem in which facts and truth don't matter. You attract attention, rouse emotions and then move on.

Those are the words of President Barack Obama quoted by David Remnick, the editor of The New Yorker in Remnick's forthcoming article "It Happened Here," a president confronts an election that changes everything and threatens his legacy. The article is based on Remnick's conversations with Obama just before and a few days after Election Day. And David Remnick joins us from New York. Welcome once again to the program.

DAVID REMNICK: Good to talk to you.

SIEGEL: First, the new ecosystem - explain what Barack Obama meant by that.

REMNICK: The new ecosystem of media, meaning a kind of post-fact world in which on Facebook, an article in The New York Times has the same seeming heft as an article about how Pope Francis endorsed Trump for president. In other words, fake news. It's an entirely different way of viewing the world, one largely based on fact and one largely on the opposite.

SIEGEL: And this isn't just your observation. President Obama talks about how the findings of scientists can be disputed by one guy who works for the Koch brothers, I think is his word, and that's considered a square off.

REMNICK: Well, look, exactly. In other words, in the old days - this is his point - when 99 percent of scientists agreed on something like climate change, you would then have an argument about means. How do you go about getting rid of acid rain? You didn't have a political argument about whether acid rain existed or not.

Now you have the prospect of somebody who might lead the Environmental Protection Agency who has spent the better part of his career denying climate change is the result of human activity. That is deeply worrying.

SIEGEL: In that quotation that I read, he speaks of emotions. You were searching for some emotions on his part in your talks with him before and just after Election Day, emotions about seeing what he's done jeopardized. And the way you describe him, he was completely cool and analytical, no wrenching of the presidential gut detectable.

REMNICK: Well, I think this is the personality we've always known, that Obama is somebody that, at least in public and even often in private, is somebody who has this - call it professorial or lawyerly or the capacity to view things either as an ethnographer or from the outside in. Even himself, he's able to analyze himself in that dispassionate way. He's a man of great discipline and especially now.

SIEGEL: We saw Obama and Trump sitting together after their private meeting. Donald Trump seemed to be very impressed that it had run so long. Obama was very respectful of Mr. Trump. How do you read that scene?

REMNICK: As a journalist, I wish I had the inner transcripts of what's running through the minds of both Barack Obama and Donald Trump. You know, if you have observed the career of Donald Trump and you see Donald Trump the way Obama does, you are very worried. You're worried about your own legacy, whether it's health care, the Iran nuclear deal or a myriad things, and you're worried also about the temperament...


REMNICK: ...Of the new president.

SIEGEL: The title of your article is "It Happened Here." I take that as an allusion to "It Can't Happen Here," Sinclair Lewis's novel about a fascist coming to power in America.

REMNICK: Exactly.

SIEGEL: Through the title, that's The New Yorker's implied evaluation of the election of Donald Trump. Is that Barack Obama's evaluation of the election of Donald Trump?

REMNICK: Well, he's very careful not to say it explicitly. But I think he looks at it as a worst-case scenario or a best-case scenario. The best-case scenario is a kind of normalized Republican conservative period.

But there's a worst-case scenario that's far worse in which the more authoritarian tendencies, the Trump that attacks the First Amendment, that all those tendencies - and we can list them from one to 50, whether it's racism or misogyny, he worries deeply that this is outside the bounds of what America is accustomed to.

SIEGEL: You describe him after election night comforting his staff, reminding them of his loss in the New Hampshire primary. He recalls David Axelrod telling him that night, you don't seem upset, and he says, you know, I think this is right. I think this is how it should be. I haven't earned this yet, meaning he hadn't earned the Democratic nomination yet.

Do you think he's that at peace with his own defeat or the rejection of Hillary Clinton, who would have been seen as somebody continuing his presidency?

REMNICK: No, I don't. I absolutely do not. You know, what - the first thing he said to his staff is this is not the apocalypse. Now, usually after an electoral defeat, you don't raise even the specter of the apocalypse. In the Oval Office, in an interview after the election - and I raised this notion of apocalypse - he says, I don't believe in the apocalyptic until it is the apocalypse. I don't believe in the end of time until it actually is.

He is struggling for a rhetoric and a spirit of optimism to salvage the day. If I know him at all and if I understand him at all, there is no way that he doesn't sense this as a grievous and alarming turn in history.

SIEGEL: David Remnick, thanks for talking with us today.

REMNICK: Always a pleasure.

SIEGEL: David Remnick's article in the next issue of The New Yorker is called "It Happened Here." The title online by the way is different. It's "Obama Reckons With A Trump Presidency."

Copyright © 2016 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.