A Painless Way To Hold Down Health Costs? While opponents of the overhaul proposals currently under consideration warn of long waits for care or draconian cuts in payments to doctors and hospitals, some experts say slowing the growth of health spending doesn't have to hurt. "You can deliver high-quality care for far fewer resources if you organize your processes right," says one expert.

A Painless Way To Hold Down Health Costs?

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/106028653/106033934" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Good morning, this is MORNING EDITION from NPR News. I'm Renee Montagne.


NPR's Julie Rovner reports.

JULIE ROVNER: The health care cost debate pretty much comes down to this: You can't cut costs without hurting someone. Here is how former Republican senator Fred Thompson put it recently on "Meet the Press."

FRED THOMPSON: The only way to really save costs is to have rationing, or it can be done by a crown(ph) down by the government and take it out of the hides of doctors and hospitals.

ROVNER: But some people think there is a third choice. Find a way to make the entire country deliver care as cost effectively as some parts of the country already do. The ideal health system already exists, says Len Nichols of the New America Foundation.

LEN NICHOLS: It exists in Grand Junction, Colorado, it exists in Billings, Montana, it exists in Denver Health, it exists in lots of places where people have figured out how to align the incentives of providers and patients so that they deliver higher quality care, more reliably, safer and at lower costs.

ROVNER: One thing those systems do that most others don't says Nichols, is coordinate care between doctors and hospitals. For example when a patient is released from the hospital, often he or she will go home with new medications and often a confused patient will go back to the old medications or take the news ones wrong. But in a coordinated system a nurse will make a phone call after a patient gets home to follow up. Nichols says something as simple as that can keep the patient on track and prevent a costly readmission to the hospital.

NICHOLS: We probably have about 20 percent of our Medicare patients are readmitted to the hospital every time. It ought to be about three percent. In those communities I named at the beginning, it is about three percent and they're doing it right because they are making sure the communication to patient is clear.

ROVNER: But it's not just that the lower spending areas of the country are doing a better job, say health experts, there's growing evidence, though still controversial, that places where medical spending is higher are doing a worse job, says doctor and researcher Elliott Fisher.

ELLIOTT FISHER: There is a very consistent picture that the higher spending regions of the United States are not delivering care as effectively, or as efficiently, or as of high quality, as the lower spending regions.

ROVNER: Fisher runs the Dartmouth Atlas Project, which has been documenting how health care is delivered differently in different parts of the country for more than 20 years. He says one big hallmark of the high spending areas is that patients there have many more doctors, particularly more specialists.

FISHER: Patients in those higher spending communities are twice as likely to have 10 or more different physicians involved in their care. And it's really hard for physicians to maintain effective communication when there are so many more of them involved in a patient's care.

ROVNER: Which leads to problems and more expensive care that might have been avoided. What Fisher would like to see and what many in Congress are looking at, are new ways of paying doctors and hospitals. These revamped payment systems would give out bonuses for keeping patient healthy, instead of paying for every service provided which encourages doctors to see more and more patients for shorter and shorter visits.

FISHER: There are dozens of physician organizations and communities around the country that are very interested in coming together to try to form organized systems in which they could be rewarded for slowing the growth of spending rather than simply the current fee-for-service practices that we are currently rewarding at the time.

ROVNER: There's a problem, however, with getting the high spending parts of the country to act more like the low spending ones.

JOE ANTOS: We don't know how to do it. What we are really talking about is changing the way medicine is practiced, and that is not a price issue.

ROVNER: Joe Antos is a policy analyst with American Enterprise Institute. He says Congress should change the payment system for doctors and hospitals, but it shouldn't bet the farm on the savings that those changes might produce.

ANTOS: It would be great if it were true. But realistically, we've been talking about many of these ideas for a couple of decades now.

ROVNER: Julie Rovner, NPR News, Washington.

Copyright © 2009 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.