How One Night In LA Illustrates The Growing Tension Between Police And The Press
ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:
Late in March of last year, police descended on a homeless encampment at Echo Park Lake in Los Angeles.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED JOURNALIST: Breaking news. It appears the crackdown has finally begun tonight to clean up one of LA's largest homeless camps.
SHAPIRO: As the news spread, activists began gathering.
(SOUNDBITE OF PROTEST)
SHAPIRO: Their protests were directed at the police who had orders to clear the park and then the streets.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTER: LAPD.
UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTERS: You won't win.
UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTER: LAPD.
SHAPIRO: Reporters rushed to Echo Park, too.
LEXIS-OLIVIER RAY: That was kind of my beat - housing, homelessness, cops, the intersection of all three.
SHAPIRO: Lexis-Olivier Ray writes for a culture and news website called LA Taco.
RAY: It was like one of the most covered event stories that I've ever reported on.
SHAPIRO: Police tried to direct the reporters to a staging ground outside the park and away from the most intense protests.
KATE CAGLE: How do I tell a story that now I don't even have access to?
SHAPIRO: Kate Cagle, a reporter for Spectrum News 1 in LA, was there to capture what happened when the police swept through the camp, displacing nearly 200 people. Instead, she got caught in the middle.
CAGLE: Wait. I'm with Spectrum News 1. They have my name. Wait. I have to stay with my crew.
SHAPIRO: Police zip-tied Cagle's wrists and move her away from the scene moments before she was to go on air.
CAGLE: I have a clip of me holding up my press pass next to my face, saying, like, hey, I'm press. This is my crew. We just want to go. And they said, no, you have to stay.
SHAPIRO: CONSIDER THIS - over the past two years, about 200 journalists across the country have been detained or arrested while on the job. Many were covering social justice protests.
CAGLE: When I saw the police officers, I no longer felt like they were providing safety for me.
SHAPIRO: Coming up, we'll look at the growing tension between police and the press through the lens of one chaotic night in LA. From NPR, I'm Ari Shapiro. It's Friday, April 29.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
SHAPIRO: It's CONSIDER THIS FROM NPR. That night at LA's Echo Park Lake in March 2021 was bigger than one night of chaos.
DAVID FOLKENFLIK, BYLINE: It seemed to me a moment where we could look at a single night and use that as a prism through which to look at this larger dynamic and to explore what got us to that point.
SHAPIRO: That's NPR's David Folkenflik. He and NPR producer Mark Rivers spent time in Echo Park Lake recently talking to reporters who were there that night about what happened.
FOLKENFLIK: I wouldn't say police always love reporters, but there clearly was a shift that as things were incredibly tense for police in public settings, as they were handling at times the violence associated with these protests. Reporters were getting tear gassed. Reporters were getting detained.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
SHAPIRO: Folkenflik says that shift happened during the racial justice protests of 2020, protests that began after the murder of George Floyd by police officer Derek Chauvin in Minneapolis. Since then, there have been multiple high-profile incidents of reporters being detained forcefully by police, even after identifying themselves as press.
FOLKENFLIK: What was different about Echo Park was that although the protests got heated, it carried the emotional weight and freight of all that had come before.
SHAPIRO: Scrutiny of police actions has intensified over the last couple of years. Producer Mark Rivers says this scrutiny has led many police officers to feel targeted.
MARK RIVERS, BYLINE: And I think that sense of being targeted creates a (inaudible) kind of animosity that the press aren't going to be, quote-unquote, "objective," that that's going to be a bias against the police. And, you know, it's, I think, it's forced us to question and grapple with what exactly the police are for, what we want from the police, how the police are used. And explaining that question honestly and thoroughly is going to be one of the essential jobs of the press today.
SHAPIRO: We pick up now with more of their reporting and what they learned about that night in Echo Park.
RIVERS: Police officers zip-tied Cagle's hands behind her back. A reporter who covers criminal justice for the LA Times ***
RIVERS: was held that same way for more than an hour. Lexis-Olivier Ray was confined for even longer. In all, police detained about 200 people there, but at least 16 journalists.
FOLKENFLIK: And that's more than a quarter of all journalists detained or arrested across the nation last year. Officers formally arrested two other reporters and a social media news blogger, holding them at a police station. Police also shot two photojournalists at Echo Park with what are called less-lethal rubber bullets. One has covered combat for the LA Times. The other, a freelancer, was hit twice. Those shots left a bloody welt the size of a baseball. Adam Rose chairs the press rights committee for the LA Press Club.
ADAM ROSE: These are things that would chill what we would consider part of this constitutional right and the need, not just a right, but a responsibility to inform the public of how police were executing these sweeps and clearing out what they declared as unlawful assemblies.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
ROSE: Back up. Back up. All of you back the f*** up.
RIVERS: Officers gave the order to disperse, but journalists didn't realize it applied to them. Rose started tracking allegations of police mistreatment of the press in September 2020. That's when LA County sheriff's deputies tackled KPCC reporter Josie Huang as she taped them making an arrest. They arrested her, too, even though she repeatedly identified herself as a reporter.
FOLKENFLIK: Rose found a pattern around the state - reporters detained and handcuffed, shot with rubber bullets, tear gassed, their equipment seized or destroyed - in all, reporters prevented from reporting.
ROSE: In fact, it turns out that over the course of a 12-month period in California, there were at least 50 incidents where police violated the rights of members of the press in some way, shape or form.
FOLKENFLIK: During protests or riots, officers have often let reporters behind police lines to witness events. At least it's a guarded recognition of the job journalists do. At Echo Park, that recognition collapsed.
STACY SPELL: I mean, there were like tensions on top of tensions.
FOLKENFLIK: Captain Stacy Spell heads the Los Angeles Police Department's media relations division. Spell and other LAPD officials will not comment directly on that night in Echo Park due to legal challenges.
RIVERS: Even so, Spell says police officers face tough choices in handling reporters during protests.
SPELL: I want to make sure that people, if they want to gather stories, if they want to inform the public, that they have the ability to do that.
RIVERS: Of course, anyone with a smartphone can post footage online.
SPELL: When you have those, for lack of a better term, bad actors who are now blending in with the crowd, you know, representing themselves as members of the press, but they're really reflecting their own personal interests and not the interests of either a news organization or the interests of the public.
RIVERS: Ray asked why the police get to make such distinctions. Rae doesn't have an official LAPD press badge, never applied for one. And when we met, he wore a red baseball cap with an LA Taco logo perched atop his afro.
RAY: A lot of times, it feels like the cops don't believe that I'm a reporter. You know, they think that I'm a protester. And I think that definitely has a lot to do with my appearance, you know, not just like the color of my skin, but also the way I dress and, you know, kind of carry myself.
FOLKENFLIK: A May 2021 internal police memo said Ray's conduct at protests, quote, "blurs the lines between functioning as the press versus functioning as an activist." The memo provided no evidence for that characterization.
RAY: Oh, it's completely false.
FOLKENFLIK: When celebrations over the LA Dodgers World Series championship got out of hand months earlier, police officers rushed Ray.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
RAY: Member of the press. Member of the press.
UNIDENTIFIED POLICE OFFICER #2: Get up. Get up.
FOLKENFLIK: That's Ray shouting repeatedly, member of the press.
RAY: I've never even been to a protest as a protester. I don't consider myself to be a protester. That was really frustrating, really, really rubbing me the wrong way.
RIVERS: Captain Spell is himself Black. And he later called Ray to talk, seeking to build trust. Ray says he appreciated that but remains shaken.
RAY: Leaving the house was at some points like a little bit scary for me for sure. And it took a while to get over that, I think.
RIVERS: Ray says he carries himself differently now. He's more guarded. Spectrum News' Kate Cagle says she had always thought her professionalism would be respected and protected by cops in times of tumult but not anymore.
CAGLE: When I saw the police officers, I no longer felt like they were providing safety for me.
RIVERS: That they would take care of you.
CAGLE: That they would take care of me. I felt like we're on our own.
FOLKENFLIK: In 2020, California Governor Gavin Newsom vetoed a bill giving reporters more protections after law enforcement officials objected. Last fall, Newsom reversed course and signed a similar bill into law. Journalists say they're heartened but remain wary, with strong memories of Echo Park.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
SHAPIRO: That's NPR's David Folkenflik and Mark Rivers. You're listening to CONSIDER THIS FROM NPR. I'm Ari SHAPIRO.
Copyright © 2022 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.