Black Vets Were Excluded From G.I. Bill Benefits. Congress Could Fix That.
MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:
Even as World War II was still raging on both the European and Pacific fronts, America was already looking for ways to welcome soldiers home whenever the war finally came to an end. The U.S. government was worried about the return of millions of unemployed veterans, specifically about the impact on the nation's economy, an economy that had only just been revived by the war after the Depression. And there was good reason for the returning soldiers to worry, too. Just a few decades earlier, many returning World War I veterans found themselves unable to make ends meet because so many of them flooded the labor market at once, and the government struggled to help them. So this time, the government resolved not to make the same mistake.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #1: In the White House at Washington, President Roosevelt approves legislation to provide for America's war veterans in the peace to come.
KELLY: On June 22, 1944, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt signed the Servicemen's Readjustment Act, more simply known as the GI Bill. It made sure basic opportunities were waiting for soldiers on their return.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: Americans were determined that this time the men who fought for their country would find a place in it when they returned.
KELLY: Educational films were released to make sure each soldier knew what was available to them, including job counseling and unemployment benefits.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #3: If they can't find you a job right away, you'll be given $20 a week up to a limit of 52 weeks.
KELLY: By 1949, nearly 9 million veterans had raised their hands for unemployment benefits. The GI Bill also provided millions of vets with the opportunity to go to college.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #3: The government pays all of your school bills up to $500 a year and living expenses of $50 a month or $75 a month if you have dependents.
KELLY: By 1947, nearly half of all U.S. college admissions were veterans, and there were loan guarantees for vets who wanted to borrow money for a business or a home.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: A returning serviceman who was starting his own business would get a financial boost from the government. Money would be advanced to buy property or a home.
KELLY: As a result, huge chunks of the population swapped out city life for the suburbs. It reshaped America's socioeconomic and political landscape for decades to come. It was all part of that patriotic impulse to make sure no returning American soldier would be left behind.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #4: The GI Bill of Rights is not a reward or a handout or a gravy train, but rather an American way to make it easier for each man to take his place once again in the community and get some of those things for which he went to war - a job, a business, an education, a home.
KELLY: But some soldiers were left behind. Black veterans returned home to a country where segregation was still the law in many states. GI Bill benefits were doled out by local and state veterans' administrations, and many banks and universities turned Black vets away. CONSIDER THIS - the same legislation that expanded the American middle class also excluded many Black veterans and their families from that middle class. It widened the wealth gap between Black and white Americans. Now, a bill in Congress aims to repair some of that harm by paying reparations to families of Black World War II veterans. Coming up, we'll hear the stories of some of those veterans and what the money could mean for their families. From NPR, I'm Mary Louise Kelly. It's Thursday, October 27.
KELLY: It's CONSIDER THIS FROM NPR. About 1 million Black veterans served in World War II. Along with being excluded from GI Bill benefits, many were excluded from the history books, including Alan Bo Price (ph), who risked his life on D-Day on Normandy Beach. He told NPR in 2007 that Black vets were largely placed in service organizations as engineers, quartermaster or medical corps officers, but some did serve on the battlefield.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED NPR BROADCAST)
ALAN BO PRICE: We had a few infantry, the 92nd and the 93rd. They broke up the second cavalry unit and sent them to engineers. And then we had the 99 Pursue Squadron, as you know, Tuskegee Airmen. And then we had a few Black artillery. And one is the 969 Field Artillery. They call them the Bastogne Bastard. He was up with the 101st in Bastogne, and they did a tremendous job. But you don't ever hear nothing about them.
KELLY: Price said he had no reservations about fighting for America.
PRICE: I felt good by going into the service. By going into the service, I could help the cause of Afro Americans.
KELLY: But back home, it was all too clear that Black and white soldiers were not treated the same. Price recalls visiting a military post exchange store or PX and a newsstand with other returning Black soldiers from his unit.
PRICE: We came home on a ship. And we landed in Newport News, Va. And so we got off the ship. And we went to our barracks and signed. So a group of us started over to the PX, and the white MP told us that we could not go into the PX. And then, again, when we got on the train and we stopped in West Virginia, at the newsstand, a fella didn't want to serve us there. So we had problems all the way.
KELLY: George Brummell (ph) served in Vietnam with some Black World War II veterans who told him similar stories.
GEORGE BRUMMELL: They talked about some of the places that they were not able to go. I remember one gentleman talked about he was from Missouri, and while he was stationed at Fort Leonard Wood, Mo., he was told that African Americans should not be allowed to carry weapons. So he felt not only was he fighting the war during World War II, but he was also fighting segregation in white America.
KELLY: NPR's Quil Lawrence takes it from here, with the story of another World War II veteran who fought in the little known Barrage Balloon Battalion.
BILL DABNEY: When we got to shore, the first thing we did was dig in, digging in the sand.
QUIL LAWRENCE, BYLINE: Bill Dabney fought with the battalion on its first mission, the D-Day landing in Normandy.
DABNEY: And the Germans had the plane they called the Do 217.
LAWRENCE: Dabney and his men had cables attached to blimps packed with explosives high above, designed to prevent the German planes from strafing the beach where the Americans were landing.
DABNEY: There was shoot coming down. And when it went up, it was shoots (ph). It was scraping the beach. So the main purpose of the balloon was to stop the scraping and protect, you know, the aircraft, the big guns.
LAWRENCE: Still, Dabney said that he and his fellow soldiers were nearly pinned down by German gunfire from the cliffs above the beach.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
DABNEY: The fire was so heavy up in the mountains from the German side that we was really afraid there at one time.
LAWRENCE: Dabney and the entire brigade were Black. It was a segregated unit, the first to land on Omaha Beach.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
DABNEY: And I think the highest ranking Black officer was a first lieutenant. And, of course, you have white officers that would come around every so often to inspect and whatnot. But my platoon officers, they were Black.
LAWRENCE: Dabney died in 2018, but he told his story to historians at the National World War II Museum. He did not really tell his story to his family back home in Virginia.
BEULAH DABNEY: He never - he didn't talk much about his time overseas.
LAWRENCE: Beulah Dabney married Bill in 1951, and she still lives at their home in Roanoke.
BEULAH DABNEY: Otherwise, he talked very little about it. He didn't keep his uniform or any of those things. In other words, he was through with the service.
LAWRENCE: Like a lot of Black veterans were. Dabney says her husband came home from Europe, where the French treated him like a hero, to the Jim Crow South.
BEULAH DABNEY: They treated some of the prisoners who were brought to the United States better than they were treating the ex, you know, soldiers, the GIs. And, of course, you can imagine how that made them feel.
LAWRENCE: Their son, Vinny Dabney, explains.
VINNY DABNEY: One reason why we never had pictures of my dad in uniform was that coming back from the West Coast after they had been deployed to go to the Pacific theater after they fought all the way through the European theater, they noticed that they had to ride in the back of the train, but Nazi P.O.W.s got to ride in first class in the front of the train. Nazis were getting treated better than Black veterans who had put their lives on the line. So that kind of pissed my dad off.
LAWRENCE: Returning home, Black veterans quickly learned that just wearing a uniform could be a provocation, says Matthew Delmont, the author of "Half American" about Black soldiers in World War II.
MATTHEW DELMONT: Eugene Bell, who was a father of two young children, was honorably discharged from the Army, was lynched in Liberty, Miss. Sam McFadden was taken into custody by a white sheriff and killed in Suwannee County, Fla. Timothy Hood, who was a honorably discharged Marine, was shot and killed by a white streetcar conductor in Bessemer, Ala.
LAWRENCE: The list goes on. Delmont teaches history at Dartmouth. He says many Black GIs also faced a less violent form of racism, which hit their benefits.
DELMONT: The GI Bill was one of the best pieces of policy that the United States ever created - at least it was for white veterans. The fact that Black veterans weren't able to benefit from the bill in the same way is, frankly, a disgrace.
LAWRENCE: The GI Bill, with free college and an easy home loan, was federal but administered locally. Segregation was still the law in 18 mostly Southern states. In 1950s Roanoke, Va., Beulah Dabney and her son Vinny say their family couldn't get a loan.
BEULAH DABNEY: They didn't actually say that they wouldn't give me a loan, but they kept dragging it out. You know, there was always some excuse as to why it didn't go through.
V DABNEY: Nobody would honor the GI Bill because they were Black. Roanoke had a reputation as being one of the most segregated cities in the South for a long time. No banks would give them a mortgage.
LAWRENCE: The Dabneys eventually found a loan through a Black insurance executive they knew, but even then, there was redlining. So the houses they were allowed to buy were in poorer parts of town and worth less. The same goes for the GI Bill's college funds. Many universities wouldn't accept them. For white veterans, it built generational wealth, says Richard Brookshire with the Black Veterans Empowerment Coalition.
RICHARD BROOKSHIRE: Black folk were largely locked out of this really important social welfare program. Because of it, it planted the seed for long-standing economic inequality that persists today.
LAWRENCE: Brookshire's group is getting behind a bill in Congress called the GI Bill Restoration Act that would try to repair some of that harm. Now Brookshire knows that the word reparations sets off all sorts of heated rhetoric on cable news. Veterans issues are supposed to be above politics, though, he says. And so maybe helping Black veterans can be a beachhead.
BROOKSHIRE: Black vets are the most well-positioned group to push forward the conversation about reparations in this country, not only because they've been affected but because of the ways in which, you know, the United States holds up veterans and what they purport to believe veterans are owed. And so, you know, you kind of force a uncomfortable but necessary conversation.
LAWRENCE: Paying back Black veterans involves a concrete number, not like the vast, incalculable harm of slavery. Researchers at Brandeis University found that the amount owed to descendants of a Black World War II veteran is $180,000. Adjusted for today's dollars, that's how much more white veterans got out of the GI Bill compared to Black veterans in 1944. Beulah Dabney says sure that money would be welcome, but at 93, she won't dwell on it.
BEULAH DABNEY: Probably would have been able to live a little bit better. I mean, financially, we would have - wouldn't have had maybe as many problems as we did, but we were able to overcome problems that cropped up. I'm not a person who likes to revisit a lot of negative things, so I don't have a whole lot, you know, to say about it.
LAWRENCE: Her son, Vinny Dabney, says some of the damage was repaired for his dad when he got a call inviting him to return to Normandy 65 years after D-Day.
V DABNEY: My dad thought it was a gimmick. He didn't want to go. He thought it was somebody pranking him. So I had to talk him into going. I said, Dad, this is historic. You can't not go. It was quite an event. My dad got the Legion of Honor, which is equivalent to our Medal of Honor.
BEULAH DABNEY: France treated him royally when he went back. And, you know, they were very happy to have him come back, showed their appreciation for what he had done. And so, of course, that stirred up a whole lot of memories. And then he started talking more about it.
LAWRENCE: About 1 million Black veterans served during World War II. Not all of them lived long enough to get that sort of recognition or the benefits they were promised.
KELLY: NPR's Quil Lawrence reporting.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
KELLY: From NPR, it's CONSIDER THIS. I'm Mary Louise Kelly.
Copyright © 2022 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.