Surprising Areas See Growth In Green Jobs A report says the upstate New York region has the highest concentration of green jobs in the country. Another surprising name in the top 10: northeast Ohio. But critics say the numbers of jobs created are too few to justify the use of federal stimulus dollars.

Surprising Areas See Growth In Green Jobs

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Even in this time of high unemployment, some parts of the U.S. economy are adding jobs, and some of those jobs are coming from green energy and clean technology firms, some of which are growing, even though a few have gone quite publicly bankrupt. These firms are not creating as many jobs as was hoped, given the infusion of federal stimulus dollars, but they are still adding employment at a faster rate than other industries.

NPR's Wendy Kaufman has more.

WENDY KAUFMAN: When you think about green energy and its jobs, Albany, New York probably wouldn't be the first city that pops into your head. But according to a new report, the upstate New York region has the highest concentration of green jobs in the country. Another surprising name in the top 10, Cleveland and Northeast Ohio.

Unidentified Man #1: How you doing today?

Unidentified Man #2: Okay. How about you?

Unidentified Man #1: Good.

KAUFMAN: Inside this factory in Willoughby, Ohio, Ashlawn Energy is teaming with a local utility and other partners to design and build flow batteries, which when fully assembled will be as big as a house.

Mr. JOSEPH STARTARI (Ashlawn Energy): This is enormous.

KAUFMAN: That's Joseph Startari, the project manager. He explains these batteries enable utilities to collect and store energy, including wind and solar power, and then have it available to send out when customers need it.

Mr. STARTARI: It's part of the smart grid, and it takes a lot of load off the grid and it prevents brownouts and things of that nature.

KAUFMAN: Ashlawn says its project, still in the very early days, is going well and the company hopes to create a new manufacturing base and hire more than 200 people within about four years. But to get started, Ashlawn needed help, and that's where Uncle Sam came in.

Mr. STARTARI: We would not have been able to do this without stimulus funds, because there was too much risk for a private equity investor. Now there's not going to be so much risk because we can show high performance from the new designs that we're testing right now.

KAUFMAN: The company got about $3.5 million, part of the president's plan to stimulate the economy and create millions of green jobs. How many have been created by this project so far? About a dozen.

If you do the math, using stimulus dollars and the number of jobs created here and elsewhere, it looks like a big waste of taxpayer money - and that's what critics claim. Even those who support the president's green initiatives on energy policy grounds find fault with it as a jobs program.

Here's Michael Levi at the Council on Foreign Relations.

Mr. MICHAEL LEVI (Council on Foreign Relations): There were a few reasons that the stimulus spending had significant limits. The first is that you needed to invest in a lot of expensive equipment and expensive capital that would take up a lot of the money in the near term and that money wouldn't go to wages for people.

KAUFMAN: It's difficult to ascertain just how many green jobs have been created, but Mark Muro of the Brookings Institution, who has just completed a major report on the green economy, has an estimate. He says between 2003 and 2010, about 100,000 new jobs were created in the green energy and clean-tech sector. Of course not all of them can be linked to the stimulus.

Muro says that while the number of green jobs is much smaller than hoped, the number should grow in the future. And for it to grow quickly, he says...

Mr. MURO: You need really vibrant regional clusters of companies. One of our interesting findings is that places that have a degree of critical mass actually were growing faster.

KAUFMAN: Places like Albany or Northeast Ohio. That's where Rebecca Bagley of the non-profit organization NorTech does cluster development with companies, workers, funders and universities.

Ms. REBECCA BAGLEY (President and CEO, NorTech): You take all those assets, interconnect them, create opportunities that they would have challenging times creating themselves to basically accelerate growth.

KAUFMAN: And, she says, the jobs being created and likely to be created are good ones.

Ms. BAGLEY: They are jobs where you can actually be making things. That makes it extremely valuable especially for especially, you know, the Midwestern economy.

KAUFMAN: And the jobs pay well. According to the report, the median pay for green jobs is about 13 percent higher than for U.S. workers overall.

Wendy Kaufman, NPR News.

Copyright © 2011 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.