France And Germany: A Love Story : Planet Money The Franco-German relationship is so dramatic — so theatrical — it's best to tell it in song.

France And Germany: A Love Story

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


This is not the first time France and Germany have fought over money. In fact, as our Planet Money team says, like any bickering couple, they've spent centuries fighting over finances. Zoe Chace offers this play-by-play.

ZOE CHACE, BYLINE: The history of France and Germany's relationship is so dramatic, so theatrical, it's best to tell it in song.


CHACE: NPR's very own "Threepenny Opera." Our story begins in 1870. France and Germany were an unlikely couple. Back then, Germany went by the handle Prussia. And if France was a glittery homecoming queen, Prussia was a scrappy neighborhood kid. So when they got into an argument about the Spanish throne, France figured I'll show this young upstart who's boss and threw the first punch.

DAVID MARSH: It was really a war by accident.

CHACE: Historian David Marsh says a pretty bad accident for France. The Franco-Prussian war lasted just barely one year. France got crushed.

MARSH: That was a colossal humiliation. And so you could say France is still trying to get over that humiliation to this day, because that did actually mark the birth of a new Germany.

CHACE: Here's where the money comes in. Germany made France pay reparations. And even today, if you walk around Berlin, you see that French money everywhere.

CARL-LUDWIG HOLTFRERICH: It was five billion gold francs that the French had to pay.

CHACE: That's historian Carl-Ludwig Holtfrerich. He points to Berlin's iconic Victory Column - French money. The capital building, the Reichstag - French money. But most galling of all to the French, Holtfrerich says, was the gold they couldn't see.

HOLTFRERICH: Part of it, which was a nuisance to the French, was kept as a war chest.

CHACE: A war chest. The Germans took some of the reparations gold and stored it in a castle. And it just sat there, just in case there was another war.


CHACE: Of course, there were two more, World Wars I and II. Both times, the Germans charged into France to take it over.


CHACE: But this time, Germany loses the wars and has to pay massive amounts of reparations. After World War II, the pair starts thinking: Instead of fighting, maybe we should consider dating. Instead of passing all this money back and forth, let's just split the check. They started with their coal and steel industries. Historian David Marsh calls it a free trade agreement of sorts.

MARSH: I think the French knew that it wouldn't be possible to keep the Germans down for too long. And indeed, that wasn't the idea. The idea was to have a strong, vibrant Germany at the heart of a new Europe.


CHACE: Oh, the couple still fought about money. France was really pushing for a common currency. Germany was very attached to their Deutsche Mark. And the bickering might have continued forever. But the power dynamics changed. In 1989, the Berlin wall falls. Germany gets bigger. And for France, these old feelings come rushing back.

MARSH: Suddenly, France sees this rather troublesome, unquiet Eastern neighbor acquiring 20 million more people and appearing to be politically and economically much more dominate.

CHACE: France sat Germany down and said look, if you're going to be the biggest economy in Europe, you have to give up your currency.


CHACE: A lot has happened since the 1992 treaty that created the euro. Some countries got into trouble. There's talk of bailouts. But you don't see Germany turning on France, like, this is your fault. You rushed us into this. David Marsh explains why.

MARSH: It's very much against the modern genetic engineering of the Germans to want to appear to be too overtly dominant in public - particularly, vis-a-vis, the French. That makes the whole thing unusually complex, psychologically.

CHACE: And politically. And legally. France and Germany can't leave the euro, or each other.


CHACE: Zoe Chace, NPR News.


MONTAGNE: Our song was composed by Jeff Lunden and Art Perlman, and you can hear the whole thing at

Copyright © 2011 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.