The Roots: A Song Cycle For A Life Cycle Do we need a hip-hop concept album in 2011? Yes, if it's as thoughtful and poignant as undun.


Music Reviews

The Roots: A Song Cycle For A Life Cycle

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


The hip-hop band The Roots might just be the hardest working band in show business. Five nights a week, they're the house band on "Late Night with Jimmy Fallon." They're also constantly collaborating with other artists. And today, the group put out a new record. It's called "Undun," and it's a concept album about a kid coming to terms with living a life of crime. Critic Tom Moon has our review.


THE ROOTS: (Singing) Homicide or suicide, heads or tails, some think life is a living hell. Some live life just living well. I live life trying to tip the scale my way.

TOM MOON, BYLINE: It makes a weird kind of sense that Redford Stephens pins his life on a coin flip. The central character of The Roots' new song cycle tells anyone who will listen that he's rarely felt in control of his own destiny. His options started out limited and have dwindled down to street hustle or prison.


ROOTS: (Rapping) Yo, I'm always early. I never take off because I got a job. Rob Peter to pay Paul. Now, I realize it's the winner that takes all. Do what I got to do because I can't take loss. Picture me living life as if I'm some animal that consumes its own dreams like I'm a cannibal. I won't accept failure unless it's mechanical.

MOON: This is familiar territory for The Roots. Somewhere on each of the band's 10 studio albums, there's a verse about young lives trapped in urban poverty. "Undun" aims to go deeper. It focuses on one lone thoughtful kid and his responses to the frustrations of everyday life. This song, called "One Time," finds the character reflecting on his unremarkable school career, and the moment when he started to wonder, why bother?


ROOTS: (Singing) I was always late for the bus. Just once, can I be on time? Then I start to think, what's the rush, who wants to be on time? Feeling unlucky and if I ever got lucky, it's one time in this crazy world.

MOON: The downcast narrative defines all of "Undun." That mood is laced into the questioning melodies and reverberates within the haunting piano chords. There are, however, a few riveting moments when the music runs counter to the message. On "Lighthouse," the main character contemplates suicide, while the refrain radiates the exuberance of a Stevie Wonder track from the 1970s.


ROOTS: (Rapping) My hand starts bleeding, water starts receding. A feeling comes into my heart, I start believing that I actually might survive through the evening, survive my own thoughts of suicide that's competing with thoughts of trying to stay alive, which been weakened by the feeling of putting on a smile while being beaten. The fear of drowning, still diving in the deep end. The waters carried me so far, you can't reach them, and it feels like there's no one. (Singing) And no one's in the lighthouse. You're face down in the ocean, and no one's in the lighthouse. And it seems like you just screamed, there's no one there to hear the sound, and it may feel like there's no one there that cares if you drown. Face down in the ocean. (Rapping) After the love is lost...

MOON: It took me a while to grasp this Roots record. For one thing, the action doesn't unfold in chronological order. And I started out as a skeptic, anyway. Do we really need a hip-hop concept album in 2011, a time when the form is overrun with egotistic blowhards? Turns out we do when it's as thoughtful and poignant as this one.


ROOTS: (Rapping) Yo, we obviously need to tone it down a bit, running round town spending time like it's counterfeit.

SIEGEL: Our reviewer is Tom Moon. The new album from The Roots is called "Undun." You can listen to the entire record at


ROOTS: (Singing) Humble head down, low and broke like promises. Soaking and broken in a joke like comics is not enough paper to be paying folks...


You're listening to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News.

Copyright © 2011 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.