To Block Obama Nominees, Congress Forgoes Recess The end-of-year holidays have traditionally allowed presidents to bypass Congress and push through contested nominees with recess appointments. But with threats that House Republicans will stay in session over the holidays to block nominations, President Obama has tough political decisions to make.

To Block Obama Nominees, Congress Forgoes Recess

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


You're listening to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News.

This week, Senate Republicans blocked confirmation votes on two of President Obama's high-profile nominees. One is in nominated for a seat on the federal appeals court, the other to head the new Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Traditionally, the end-of-the-year holidays have allowed presidents to go around Congress and make recess appointments. But as NPR's David Welna explains, this year, that's not likely to be the case.

DAVID WELNA, BYLINE: An hour after Senate Republicans blocked an up or down vote on the nominee to head the new consumer agency, an angry President Obama was in the White House briefing room putting Congress on notice.

PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: I will not take any options off the table when it comes to getting Richard Cordray in as director of the Consumer Finance Pro

tection Board.

WELNA: But the only way the president can make a recess appointment for Cordray is if Congress is actually in recess. And ever since late May, Congress has remained in permanent session, mainly because Republican lawmakers want to prevent any more recess appointments. Donald Ritchie is the Senate's official historian. He says several presidents have used a constitutional provision that allows them to convene a session of Congress.

DONALD RITCHIE: But there is this other provision that says, well, if the two houses themselves can't agree on an adjournment, the president can adjourn Congress. It's just that no president has ever exercised that constitutional authority.

SENATOR ORRIN HATCH: It would be a very unwise political thing to do.

WELNA: That's Utah Republican Senator Orrin Hatch. He doubts President Obama would actually exercise his constitutional power to adjourn Congress in order to make recess appointments.

HATCH: It would make him look like he's stupid, because as much as he hates Congress or might hate - a more fair statement - might hate Congress, he still needs it.

WELNA: It's not likely the president would even have the option of adjourning Congress because the only way he can do that is if one chamber adjourns and the other one doesn't. House Republicans intend to remain in pro forma session throughout the holidays, and a spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid says it's likely the Senate will do the same. Congressional expert Ross Baker of Rutgers University says the chief concern of the Senate's top Democrat may be the 23 Democrats facing re-election bids next year.

ROSS BAKER: He's really in a position where he's trying to do everything he can to protect those 23 Democrats so that may or may not coincide with the interests of President Obama.

WELNA: Other presidents have tested the limits of their recess appointment powers, mainly because the question of what constitutes a congressional recess has never really been settled. Associate Senate historian Betty Koed says, in 1903, Teddy Roosevelt used an almost nonexistent congressional break to make recess appointments.

BETTY KOED: When the presiding officer brought the gavel down to end one session, he simultaneously began the next session, and in that split second it took the gavel to go down, Roosevelt appointed 193 people.

WELNA: Catholic University law professor Victor Williams says President Obama, who evoked Teddy Roosevelt repeatedly in a speech this week, should show similar audacity.

VICTOR WILLIAMS: He should not ignore the pro forma sessions. He should explicitly, deliberately challenge them.

WELNA: If he doesn't, Williams says, a pattern of pro forma sessions shutting off recess appointments that began late in the Clinton administration will only continue. Key posts in the administration will be left vacant. Oregon Democratic Senator Jeff Merkley agrees.

SENATOR JEFF MERKLEY: At some point, the abuse of process by my Republican colleagues means that the president should consider any constitutional legal means to make our government work for working Americans.

WELNA: But the president's options at this point appear very limited. David Welna, NPR News, the Capitol.

Copyright © 2011 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.