Monsanto Accused In Suit Tied To Agent Orange A class-action lawsuit claims Monsanto spread dioxin and other toxic substances when it made a primary ingredient for Agent Orange in West Virginia. Dioxin has been linked to cancer and other illnesses. At issue is whether Monsanto must pay millions to monitor the health of everyone in the case.
NPR logo

Monsanto Accused In Suit Tied To Agent Orange

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Monsanto Accused In Suit Tied To Agent Orange

Monsanto Accused In Suit Tied To Agent Orange

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


In the small town of Nitro, West Virginia, residents have filed a class action lawsuit against Monsanto. For about two decades, a Monsanto plant there produced an ingredient of Agent Orange. That's the defoliant the military sprayed over Southeast Asia during the Vietnam War. And the lawsuit claims that Monsanto polluted the town of Nitro.


NPR's Jeff Brady has the story.

JEFF BRADY, BYLINE: Nitro became a town during World War I, named after the type of gunpowder workers produced there. Later, private companies like Monsanto manufactured other chemicals in Nitro. The town's mayor, Rusty Casto, is driving along a bumpy road near the Kanawha River.

MAYOR RUSTY CASTO: All this used to be Monsanto in here. Now it's, what, a 10-foot fence and barbed wire around it.


BRADY: Getting out of his truck, Casto says growing up in Nitro the chemical industry was big.

CASTO: Well, if you ever drove over the I-64 Bridge at Nitro, you really got an odor back in the '60s and '70s, you know you been to Nitro.

BRADY: Mm-hmm. What did it smell like?

CASTO: Well, I don't know if I could describe it. It's sure - you sure knew you were going over it, it wasn't fresh air, but people were working in them days.

BRADY: The class action lawsuit was filed on behalf of tens of thousands of people who lived, worked and went to school in Nitro after 1949. Monsanto produced the herbicide 2,4,5-T there, which was used in Agent Orange. The suit claims the company spread toxic substances all over town, mainly dioxins which have been linked to cancer. At issue in this case: whether Monsanto will have to pay millions of dollars to monitor the health of everyone included in the case.

The Vietnam War connection has long-time peace activists paying attention. Jim Lewis is a retired Episcopal priest in nearby Charleston.

JIM LEWIS: We need to have the facts about what these chemicals were, what they were all about, where the residue, then, was deposited - and still affecting people.

BRADY: And, Lewis says, residents need to be fairly compensated. But back in Nitro, while most of the residents remain part of the lawsuit, many have mixed feelings about the case.


BRADY: At the senior center during lunchtime, 79-year-old Gertie Estep says she spent a decade working for a chemical plant. Most of her family was employed by Monsanto, where she says the pay was good.

GERTIE ESTEP: When we moved here we knew the plants was here. We raised our families from those plants and we had no problems. 'Course, I know a lot of people in Nitro have had cancer, but, you know, I'm not sure they can blame that on to the plants or not.

BRADY: That is one of the many issues that will be argued before a jury in court. Attorneys for the plaintiffs and for Monsanto won't comment for this story. The court has issued a gag order out of concern pre-trial publicity could sway the jury.

This is not the first time lawyers have sued Monsanto over health effects in Nitro. In the 1980s, Harvey Peyton was co-counsel in a lawsuit brought on behalf of seven former employees.

HARVEY PEYTON: We won one case. One man developed bladder cancer during the course of the trial. The jury found in his favor and awarded him some moderate damages.

BRADY: But Peyton and his colleagues lost the other cases. He's not involved in the current class-action lawsuit, but he's followed it. There's one development he finds troubling. Originally, the suit called for Monsanto to both monitor people's health and clean up polluted property. The court rejected the property claims last year, leaving just the medical monitoring.

PEYTON: So you just brand this class area as quote, "dangerous," from a health standpoint, but there's nobody to clean it up.

BRADY: The clean-up issue is still being appealed. Meanwhile, the medical monitoring case is headed to trial after settlement negotiations failed. A jury has been selected and the court says opening arguments could begin as early as February 13th.

Jeff Brady, NPR News.

Copyright © 2012 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.