Which Tablet Is Right For You? : All Tech Considered For the first time, Apple's iPad has some competition: Google's Nexus, Amazon's Kindle Fire HD and the Microsoft Surface. Tech reporters Steve Henn and Laura Sydell have been testing out the latest tablets this holiday season — and found that content is king.
NPR logo

Which Tablet Is Right For You?

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/166404319/166434237" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Which Tablet Is Right For You?

Which Tablet Is Right For You?

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/166404319/166434237" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Melissa Block.


I'm Audie Cornish. And it's time now for All Tech Considered.


CORNISH: The holiday season is upon us, and that means today in tech, we're going to talk gadgets, specifically one of the year's most popular gadgets: the tablet. And for the first time, Apple's iPad has some competition.

For a look at the field, we're joined by NPR's tech reporters Laura Sydell and Steve Henn. They join us from San Francisco in a room full of gadgets. Hey there, guys.



CORNISH: The number of tablets out there is verging on overwhelming. What have you got?

HENN: Well, we decided to look at the big tablets.

SYDELL: And the small tablets. So we're looking at the big and small version of Apple's iPad, Google's Nexus, the Amazon, the HD Fire and the new Microsoft Surface.

CORNISH: Now, out of all the tablets out there, why did you focus on these?

HENN: Well, we decided that we wanted to look at the marquee efforts by the biggest tech companies, Apple, Amazon, Microsoft and Google.

SYDELL: They also represent the four major content universes. So you will notice if you decide to buy any of these that they kind of want to keep you in their content universe. So Apple has got its store. Google has its. Amazon - it's got its store. So there's that issue, too, and we wanted to try all the content universes.

CORNISH: So first question: big or small?

SYDELL: You know, I'm going to be a proponent of the small size. I really liked the small size because you can just slip it into your purse or wherever, and it's really easy to take around. And on that front, I would say the iPad Mini, in particular, it's like only two ounces lighter than the other two. But for some reason, that made a huge difference to me. You know, when you're carrying a lot of stuff around, there's something about the two ounces that made a difference.

CORNISH: There are a lot of other little tablets that are gaining in popularity, like the Amazon Fire, Google Nexus. What did you think of those?

SYDELL: I did, indeed, try those. And, in fact, there are certain things about them that are nice. They both have better screens. Though the truth is when I watched movies on them, I couldn't tell the difference. But, really, the biggest difference is they're both cheaper, significantly. So the iPad Mini is $329 and the Nexus and the HD Fire, at the entry level, are 199. So that's a big difference. But with the HD Fire, there are commercials. So every time you...


HENN: There were ads everywhere. In the big Amazon tablet too.

SYDELL: Yeah. So with Amazon, you're going to get a commercial every time you open it up.

The other thing about the Nexus though that I liked is if you are in the Google universe and you use their documents and you use Picasa...

HENN: Their Calendar.

SYDELL: Their Calendar, which Steve uses big time.

HENN: Yeah. So I use Calendar to keep our family from heading, you know, off the cliff. And when you open up the Calendar, or any of Google's sort of Cloud-based services, the interface is beautiful. So on the Calendar, I can see everything going on in an entire month at once. And it's really kind of a striking difference. I have them here. And you open up the Google Calendar in the iPad and it just looks...

SYDELL: It doesn't look very good.


SYDELL: I can tell you right now.

HENN: Yeah. So if you live in the Google universe and the big devices, and you want to save a hundred bucks, I thought that the Nexus was a decent choice.

CORNISH: So where does all this leave the full-sized tablets, like the original iPad?

HENN: Well, I think, you know, the standard bearer for tablets, and certainly full-sized tablets, is the iPad. And, you know, the - it's a little bit more expensive than a couple of the others. It starts at $499. And honestly, I wasn't completely gaga about it. The Wi-Fi had a smaller range than the other three tablets I tested, so it didn't work in my bedroom. And some of those Cloud-based services aren't so hot. The maps got me lost in Atlanta.

The real strength of the iPad is its ecosystem, 270,000 apps. There's something for everyone. So it's, you know, it's tough to beat on that front. Amazon has a lot of movies and content. And actually, when I was downloading a kid's movie - I downloaded the same movie on the iPad - the Amazon tablet downloaded 10 times faster. And it's also much cheaper. It's $200 less than the competitive tablet from Apple.

So the downside, I couldn't really work on it. If I tried to do email on a - the Amazon tablet, I kind of end up pulling my hair out.

CORNISH: And speaking of work, I want to turn to the Office software workhorse Microsoft. They're getting into tablets, and they seem to seem to be aiming at folks who want to use a tablet for more than play.

HENN: Yeah. And they're doing some nice things. They have something called Skydrive that let's you sync all of your Office documents or spreadsheets in the Cloud, and that works really well. But the problem is the Windows RT, which is - runs the Surface. It's a new ecosystem, so there are some kinks. But the table itself, physically, it's a beautiful machine. It has a little kickstand. It has a cover that doubles as a keyboard, which was great.

But at this point, there were things about it that would prevent me from recommending it. It didn't work with a hotel Wi-Fi I was at, so it basically became useless. It has promise, but I'd give it a little bit more time.

SYDELL: Well, and again, you want to emphasize it doesn't have much content. And when you are buying these devices, to some degree, you're buying into a different content universe. So you have decisions to make. If you want to spend a little more, you go for Apple, but you're going to be kind of locked into their universe with each, you know, with the Surface. And Microsoft really has the least content available in its universe at this point.

HENN: Well, actually - I mean, they have a lot of stuff, but it's only from Microsoft. So they don't have Spotify. They don't have Pandora. If you want to listen to music, you have to listen to Xbox Music. So...

SYDELL: Right.

CORNISH: All right, guys. Thanks so much. NPR tech reporters Laura Sydell and Steve Henn, thank you.

SYDELL: You're welcome.

HENN: Our pleasure.

Copyright © 2012 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.