Government Slowly Changes Approach To Whistle-Blowers : It's All Politics The federal government once considered whistle-blowers a nuisance, or worse. But over the past few years, that attitude has slowly started to change. More agencies have been reaching out for tips about fraud and abuse, even if digging through the stacks of complaints can present a challenge.

Government Slowly Changes Approach To Whistle-Blowers

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


The federal government once considered whistleblowers a nuisance or even worse. Over the past few years that attitude has slowly changed. More agencies have been reaching out for tips about fraud and abuse in and outside the government, despite the challenges of digging through stacks of complaints. NPR's Carrie Johnson has more.

CARRIE JOHNSON, BYLINE: Think back to those movies in the 1970s filled with heroic figures who risked it all to expose unsafe factories and police corruption, like New York cop Frank Serpico and his less-than-clean colleagues.


UNIDENTIFIED MAN: We're not doing anything bad here. We're skimming a little gambling money. It's clean.

JOHNSON: Whistle-blower lawyer Neil Getnick says the people in those tales usually came to a sad end.

NEIL GETNICK: And unfortunately all the stories had pretty much the same plot line. Something bad happened with an organization. A person stood up to do something about it. That person changed things for the better. And their life was changed for the worse.

JOHNSON: The federal government says it's trying to do something about that. Last November, President Obama signed a whistle-blower protection law after a 13-year campaign by good government groups. The law makes clear that federal employees can challenge policy decisions without losing their jobs. It also directs agencies to choose a point person to help whistle-blowers understand their rights.

At the Justice Department that person is Robert Storch. He says they got almost 5,000 complaints in 2012, allegations like these.

ROBERT STORCH: Nepotism and improper hiring practices within the department, and that actually started with a whistleblower complaint that went to Congressman Wolf's office, in this case, and the congressman referred that matter to our office.

JOHNSON: Justice watchdogs dug into the case. They found eight high-ranking people in the Justice Management unit broke the rules by getting relatives hired. But with thousands of phone calls and emails coming in, it can be tough to decide which ones deserve attention. Patrick Burns has some tips. Burns works at the group Taxpayers Against Fraud, where he talks with scores of whistle-blowers every year.

PATRICK BURNS: I ask only two questions. Tell me how you know about the fraud. And tell me about the fraud. Those two questions, if you listen carefully, will tell you a great deal.

JOHNSON: Things like how high up in the chain of command someone is and how deeply they're connected to the wrongdoing. Burns says he also gives callers an important piece of advice.

BURNS: Do not report within a company until you have gotten the documents outside the building. Because when you report on a Monday, they'll pat you on the head and say thank you. And on Friday they're going to march you out the door.

JOHNSON: That's what happened to Cheryl Eckard. She was a quality control manager at the drug company GSK, until she blew the whistle on sloppy practices at a plant in Puerto Rico. Eckard was laid off, but she followed through by calling federal regulators and the Justice Department. After years of waiting, Eckard collected a share of the legal settlement, estimated at $96 million.

It's the biggest financial reward ever for a whistle-blower under a law called the False Claims Act. But Eckard says it was far from easy. She lost friends. She gained weight. She worried about how to pay her mortgage.

CHERYL ECKARD: When you're in it, it feels like it will never end. But there will be an end. It may take eight years, but there'll be an end to it. So the people who are caught in the middle of that process right now have, you know, hope and faith. It won't last forever.

JOHNSON: U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara, the top federal prosecutor in New York, says changing the culture is what counts.

PREET BHARARA: We find in too many instances there have been whistle-blowers who have come forward earlier on in the cases that we have brought and a lot of pain and suffering would have been avoided, and a lot of expenses would have been avoided, and some people might not have been going to jail if people had taken more seriously the allegations of whistle-blowers years earlier.

JOHNSON: It doesn't matter how loud someone blows the whistle, Bharara says, if the referee covers his ears. Carrie Johnson, NPR News, Washington.

Copyright © 2013 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.