Resurrected Frog Gives Us Cause To Brood This week scientists announced they have reproduced the genome of an extinct amphibian, the gastric brooding frog. But animals are more than just their genomes, so NPR's Scott Simon wonders if it's necessary — or kind — to bring them back.

Resurrected Frog Gives Us Cause To Brood

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


The gastric brooding frog may be coming back. Does that give us a lot to brood about too? This week, scientists at the University of New South Wales's Lazarus Project announced they have reproduced the genome, that bit of biological material that carries our genetic structure, of a gastric brooding frog. The gastric brooder once lived in the rainforests of Queensland, Australia, and was declared extinct in 1983. It was not so named because it had the temperament of a Russell Crowe character, but because it gave birth through its mouth. So, if you heard a female gastric brooder croak excuse me while I clear my throat, you stood back.

Professor Mike Archer says his team took tissue from a frog who's been dead and frozen since the 1970s and implanted it successfully in an egg from a closely related frog species. The embryo survived just a few days, but even a brief existence stirred excitement, that this technique could lead to a way of recreating lost species. We're increasingly confident the hurdles ahead are technological, not biological, Professor Archer told the Guardian newspaper, and added they've already begun work on cloning a Tasmanian tiger, which disappeared in the 1930s. Returning the Tasmanian tiger to life on earth can seem to be a grace note of justice in a natural world that on its own can be nasty, brutish and short, as Thomas Hobbes phrased it.

Other predators, including dingoes and human beings, are thought to have hunted the Tasmanian tiger to extinction. So, isn't it somehow apt that human scientists apply their ingenuity to help bring him and other species back? Except, as some scientists and ethicists have pointed out, animals are not just their genomes. You might someday be able to bring back some incarnation of a Tasmanian tiger, but is he truly a Tasmanian tiger if there's not a parent around to show him how to be one? Would a Tasmanian tiger cloned and brought to life in a lab be just some kind of living, breathing facsimile, the way that Las Vegas creates replica Venetian canals or the Eiffel Tower? How necessary or kind would it be to create that kind of Tasmanian tiger? Right now, a species is irreplaceable; that's why they're precious. I wonder if there are a few other things scientists could work to bring back from extinction first, like thank you notes, 24-hour diners, condolence notes, people saying ma'am and sir to strangers and base-runners stealing home on a two-strike pitch.


SIMON: You're listening to NPR News.

Copyright © 2013 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.