Who's Hiring H-1B Visa Workers? It's Not Who You Might Think : All Tech Considered There's been increasing support for the number of H1-B visas given to highly skilled workers. Large tech companies are leading the push for the increase, but the bulk of the visas go to workers at large consulting firms.
NPR logo

Who's Hiring H-1B Visa Workers? It's Not Who You Might Think

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/176134694/176166641" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Who's Hiring H-1B Visa Workers? It's Not Who You Might Think

Who's Hiring H-1B Visa Workers? It's Not Who You Might Think

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/176134694/176166641" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Well, now, to another issue occupying the president and the Congress, immigration, specifically the push for more H-1B visas. These are visas for workers from overseas with specialized skills - researchers, for instance, or software engineers. American tech companies are lobbying hard for an increase in H-1B visas. Here's Microsoft's point man on the issue, Brad Smith.

BRAD SMITH: We need to continue to attract some of the best and brightest people in the world to come and join us in world-leading R&D efforts.

SIEGEL: Well, that best and brightest argument doesn't always match with the reality of how H-1B visas are used. That's what NPR's Martin Kaste found when he looked at the companies using the most H-1Bs.

MARTIN KASTE, BYLINE: If you scroll through the government's visa data, you notice something surprising. The biggest employer of these foreign tech workers is not Microsoft. Not by a long shot. Nor is it Google or Facebook or any other name brand tech company. The biggest user of H-1Bs are consulting companies or, as Ron Hira calls them, offshore outsourcing firms.

RON HIRA: The top 10 recipients in the last fiscal year are all offshore outsourcers, and they got 40,000 of the 85,000 visas, which is astonishing.

KASTE: Hira is a professor of public policy at the Rochester Institute of Technology. He's also the son of Indian immigrants, so he has a personal interest in questions of labor flow across borders. For the past decade, he's been studying how consulting firms use temporary work visas to help American companies cut costs. He says they use the visas both to supply cheaper workers here, but also to smooth the transfer of American jobs to IT centers overseas.

HIRA: What these firms have done is exploit the loopholes in the H-1B program to bring in onsite workers to learn the jobs of the Americans, to then ship it back offshore and also to bring in onsite workers who are cheaper on the H-1B and undercut American workers right here.

KASTE: The biggest user of H-1Bs last year was Cognizant, a firm based in New Jersey. They got 9,000 new visas. Following close behind are Infosys, Wipro and Tata, all Indian firms. They're not household names, but they loom large in techie places like the Seattle suburbs.

Rennie Sawade is a software designer with 30 years experience. He grew up in Michigan watching the decline of the auto industry, so he went into computers in search of a more secure career. But that's not how it turned out.

RENNIE SAWADE: Basically, what I see is it's happening all over again.

KASTE: Programmers like him tend to be freelancers, contract workers and the big consulting firms are the competition. Sawade recalls the time he almost landed a plumb job at Microsoft.

SAWADE: I remember having phone interviews and talking with a manager, having them sound really excited about my experience and that he was going to bring me into meet the team.

KASTE: And then, nothing. He called his own placement agency to find out what had happened.

SAWADE: And that's when they told me, oh, they hired somebody from Tata Consultancy. And then she told me on the phone, the woman I was talking to, said, her jaw just dropped when they found out how little Microsoft was paying this person from Tata Consultancy to do this job.

KASTE: Sawade is active in a labor organization called WashTech, so he gets the complaints from IT workers around the country. The H-1B consulting firms are especially active in banking, insurance, and pretty much any industry that runs on big computer systems maintained by aging, increasingly expensive American tech workers. He laughs at the notion that a cost-cutting insurance company somewhere is in dire need of hotshot foreign programmers with specialized skills.

SAWADE: They require that the current employees are in that department to train the people they bring over from India. And maybe not - the people in India are not necessarily there to replace them, at least not right away. They're just learning the job.

KASTE: Learning the job, he says, so the consulting firm can eventually provide the same service from somewhere cheaper. NPR tried repeatedly to get interviews with the biggest H-1B users, but none would agree to talk. We did reach Dean Garfield, head of the Information Technology Industry Council, which counts Cognizant among its members.

DEAN GARFIELD: Some of the companies are companies, yes, that are providing services that bring greater efficiencies to businesses. But what's wrong with that?

KASTE: Garfield rejects the notion that Cognizant is using foreign tech workers to undercut Americans. He points out that H-1B workers are supposed to be paid prevailing wages. In practice, though, that rule is rarely enforced. In a 2011 report, the U.S. Government Accountability Office said worker protections are, quote, "weakened by several factors" and that oversight is, quote, "cursory." Garfield acknowledges the system is not perfect.

GARFIELD: The main, legitimate criticism right now - which is one we would level as well - is that the accountability mechanisms are not fully integrated and not seamless. It's more a check the box.

KASTE: But he also takes exception to criticism that lumps the consulting firms together, something he calls offensive.

GARFIELD: There is a lot of anti-India sentiment in many of the criticisms and articles around this that I think are completely unfounded and unnecessary.

KASTE: But it's not offensive to Neeraj Gupta.

NEERAJ GUPTA: I'm a U.S. citizen. I came to the country on a student visa for my master's in electrical engineering.

KASTE: Gupta spent part of his career working for an Indian consulting firm Patni. And he says, it was obvious they were using H-1B workers to replace Americans.

GUPTA: Oh, almost every one of our projects was like that.

KASTE: On some of those projects, he says, even the clients had misgivings.

GUPTA: I had people come to me and tell me that the number one issue that they faced - and even as they were offering this work - was the fact that they had longstanding employees and the implications of them losing their jobs.

KASTE: He now runs what he calls a domestic outsourcing company. It's also a consulting firm, but his workers are American. So he does have an incentive to criticize the H-1B system. At the same time, he doesn't want to eliminate it. He believes American tech companies are in dire need of highly skilled foreign workers. The problem, he says, is that so many of the visas are gobbled up for middle-of-the-road tech jobs already being done by Americans.

Martin Kaste, NPR News, Seattle.

Copyright © 2013 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.