States' Refusal To Expand Medicaid May Leave Millions Uninsured : Shots - Health News The idea was that Medicaid would expand to include people not covered under the Affordable Care Act. But many states have chosen not to expand coverage, despite financial incentives from the federal government. That may leave millions of people without any health coverage at all.

States' Refusal To Expand Medicaid May Leave Millions Uninsured

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


You've made it to Wednesday along with MORNING EDITION from NPR News. I'm Steve Inskeep.


And I'm David Greene, good morning. The Obama administration is trying to fix the troubled website To help, they've drafted a management guru named Jeffrey Zeints. is where, in theory, consumers can shop for health insurance. I say in theory because there have been some embarrassing glitches.

Now, even if Zeints and his team get the site working, at some point millions of low-income Americans are going to discover they are not eligible for any health coverage at all. That's not due to any glitch. It's because their state has decided not to expand Medicaid. NPR's Julie Rovner explains.

JULIE ROVNER, BYLINE: This is not the way the health law was originally designed and enacted.

BRUCE SIEGEL: Originally the idea was that millions and millions of Americans would get health insurance. They'd get coverage through Medicaid or through private insurance on the exchanges.

ROVNER: Bruce Siegel represents safety net institutions around the country as president and CEO of America's Essential Hospitals. Expanding Medicaid was a major piece of the health law, he says.

SIEGEL: Medicaid was supposed to be expanded by covering people who weren't eligible today, people who were fairly poor.

ROVNER: Meaning those with incomes up to about one and a third times the federal poverty level or about $15,000 for an individual. Right now in most states you have to be either a child or pregnant or disabled to get Medicaid. The health law was supposed to change all that, expanding the program to nearly everyone with low incomes.

But in the summer of 2012, when the Supreme Court upheld the health law as constitutional, it did something unexpected.

SIEGEL: They said that states had the option of expanding their Medicaid program or not expanding it. And that led to a very, very different landscape than what we expected.

ROVNER: Only half the states so far have opted to expand their Medicaid programs, even though the federal government is paying the entire cost of the additional people for the first three years, and 90 percent going forward. As a result, according to the Urban Institute, between six and seven million low-income uninsured adults live in states that are so far not expanding their programs.

GENEVIEVE KENNEY: Over three million of them live in just four states - Florida, Texas, Georgia and North Carolina.

ROVNER: That's Urban Institute's senior fellow, Genevieve Kenney. The problem, says Kenney, is that for many of those people, the law offers them nothing. Because they were supposed to get Medicaid, they're not eligible to buy private insurance at the exchanges unless their incomes are over the poverty line. That's about $11,000 a year for an individual.

KENNEY: I think it's going to be confusing for individuals who are applying for coverage. It certainly makes the message about the new affordable coverage that's available a lot more complicated to target.

ROVNER: Among those who could be left out is Ellen Wall. She's a nanny and sometime music teacher from Atlanta. She says her income fluctuates, but most years it's right around the poverty line. She says as long as she can pay her bills, she doesn't mind earning that amount.

ELLEN WALL: I love doing what I do because I'm very good at what I do; that's why I've chosen this profession. But there are those years when it's quite lean and then, you know, I'm just barely making it. But then what am I going to do if something comes up and I'm really sick and I need some help?

ROVNER: Wall doesn't have and hasn't had health insurance. She says that was a real problem a few years back when she was in the hospital after an asthma attack.

WALL: It was kind of a very embarrassing situation to be in, not to have the health insurance that could have covered that few days that I was in the hospital.

ROVNER: If Wall lived in a state expanding Medicaid, she would clearly qualify. But so far, Georgia isn't. And her income may or may not be high enough to let her qualify for help buying private coverage on the state's exchange. So she'll likely remain working, poor and uninsured.

Most advocates say people like Wall should turn to community clinics and public hospitals if they can't get insurance. But there's a problem there too, says public hospital advocate Bruce Siegel. The health law cuts funding for public hospitals because it assumes so many more people would have insurance. But in those states that aren't expanding Medicaid, the need for free care is likely to go up instead of down.

SIEGEL: Many of these hospitals will be overwhelmed. Some of them are already overwhelmed. Many of them are already losing money, providing a high level of service to people in need. And this will simply not be a tenable position.

ROVNER: Ohio this week became the 25th state to vote to expand Medicaid, but despite lobbying efforts by hospitals and even the business community in some places, many states remain firmly opposed, which means patients left behind may have to scramble even harder to find care if they get sick. Julie Rover, NPR News.

Copyright © 2013 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.