Democratic Sen. Landrieu Walks A Fine Line In Red Louisiana The Democrat has won some conservatives in the state with her strong defense of the oil industry. But her support for Obamacare may sink her.

Democratic Sen. Landrieu Walks A Fine Line In Red Louisiana

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


And if Democrats are going to keep their majority in the Senate, they will need to hang on to a few critical seats they hold in conservative states. Senator Mary Landrieu of Louisiana has one of those and, like some of her colleagues up for re-election, her support of the Affordable Care Act could be the big challenge to overcome this fall.

Mention the health care law in Lafourche Parish and this is what you'll hear.

AL WILLIAMS: I don't like Obamacare. If she's supporting it, I wouldn't vote for her.

MONTAGNE: That's Al Williams, an oil worker. He was one of many people who talked to NPR's Ailsa Chang. She traveled down to South Louisiana to see if voters there define Landrieu by Obamacare or judge her by her two decades in office.


AILSA CHANG, BYLINE: There's a sprawling, twisty live oak in Galliano, Louisiana. You'll see it when you're driving down the bayou.


CHANG: The Cajuns here call the old tree Chene au Cowan. And nearly every day from sun-up to sundown, you'll find a group of retired Cajun men sitting on swings beneath the branches, just talking life and politics. The man who's been gathering them lately is 75-year-old Stanley Gisclair.

So how many years have you guys been gathering under this oak tree?


STANLEY GISCLAIR: About 50 years? Sixty years, something like that or more? How long we've been (unintelligible) with the tree? Like 50...

BEAU BROUSSARD: Oh, at least 50 years.

GISCLAIR: About 50 years.

CHANG: That other guy is Beau Broussard. He's not Cajun but they let him hang out here anyway. Broussard says for years, people running for political office have visited this oak tree.

BROUSSARD: They don't run without coming here 'cause that's good luck here.

CHANG: Old campaign signs are still hanging all over the tree trunk. Broussard fondly remembers the last candidate who stopped by.

BROUSSARD: He brought some white beans. And, lady, they were delicious. Ooh, I'd vote for him just for them white bean.


BROUSSARD: Oh, me. I don't even remember who - what he running for.

CHANG: It will take a lot more than a pot of white beans to get Broussard to vote for one particular candidate this November, Democratic Senator Mary Landrieu. The deal-breaker for him was when she voted for the Affordable Care Act. Now, Broussard has all kinds of problems with the law itself; that it's wrong to force people to buy insurance, that it will make businesses hire less. But there's something else that bothers him. The law is the signature achievement of President Obama.

Did you vote for Obama in 2008?


CHANG: Why not? So that was before Obamacare. Why didn't you...

BROUSSARD: Uh-uh. I don't vote for black people, lady. No, ma'am. I don't vote for black people. They got their place. I got my place. That's the way I was raised.

CHANG: So how much of you that doesn't like Landrieu is really about you not liking Obama? Are the two inseparable in your mind?

BROUSSARD: No. Uh-uh. If she hadn't voted for Obamacare, I'd still vote for her. Oh, no.

CHANG: That's what did it.

BROUSSARD: Because she helped the people.

CHANG: Because she helped the people. Voters in Louisiana acknowledge how much Landrieu has helped her state. But she's associated with two things many people here resent - the health care law and the president behind it. So the challenge now for Landrieu is, can she persuade those voters to forgive her, by convincing them she'll deliver for her home state in other ways? Like for oil and gas - the largest industry in the state.


CHANG: You can find a lot of oil workers who want to keep Landrieu around if you travel down to Port Fourchon, on the Gulf of Mexico. This is where Louisiana's offshore oil and gas industry is concentrated.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: Did y'all have a shrimp salad and Fourchon Burger? Which one had which?

CHANG: This is Kajun Buffet, the lunch place for the oil workers here. Chad Plaisance says the key to winning his vote isn't political party.

CHAD PLAISANCE: To tell you the truth, it don't matter which way I am. If I like who's running, that's how I vote. If they going to something good for South Louisiana, the oil field and the shrimping industry, it don't matter what I'm registered as.

CHANG: He says he's willing to overlook Obamacare, as much as he hates it because of all the ways Landrieu has helped his industry. She's pushing to increase Louisiana's royalties from offshore oil revenues. And he remembers how fiercely she opposed the moratorium on offshore drilling right after the BP oil spill. He was really grateful for that.

PLAISANCE: Yes ma'am, because we work on the supply boats. If the supply boats don't run, then we don't have a job. So it's kind of - oil field don't work, we don't work.

CHANG: Landrieu's also just become chair of the Senate Energy Committee this month, a position that will give her even more influence over the industry. That's a detail Harvey Robichaux says will earn his vote.

HARVEY ROBICHAUX: She has done a lot of good and she has a lot of seniority. So I would be willing to vote Democrat because of that seniority. And I wouldn't want to give it up.

CHANG: But that seniority will not prove as helpful with other Louisiana industries, like shrimping. Up the road a bit is a marina in Leeville, where a lot of shrimpers load up on ice before they head out into the Gulf.


CHANG: Parish Williams runs Chackbay Lady, his 52-foot shrimp boat.

All right, can you - can you help me up?

PARISH WILLIAMS: Yeah, just put your foot in the hole and climb over. Like that.

CHANG: Williams' family has been shrimping for five generations. He says they've seen the business go through some really tough times and that Landrieu hasn't done enough to help them. The stress really started to build around the year 2000, when shrimp imports shot up.

WILLIAMS: It drove the price of the shrimp down to hardly nothing where we could barely make a living for quite awhile. This year's the first year we started to get a decent price.

CHANG: And Williams says that good fortune had nothing to do with Landrieu. A strain of bacteria ended up killing off loads of foreign shrimp. So his business rebounded. But once the bacteria problem's solved, he says shrimpers will suffer again.

Now, Landrieu's office points out that she has protected shrimpers - she successfully pushed for import duties on shrimp coming from parts of Asia. But Williams says, it didn't help much, and it certainly wasn't enough to make up for her support of Obamacare.

WILLIAMS: I think she's been there too long. I think she's too comfortable. I think it's time for her to go.

CHANG: When Landrieu became one of the most vocal critics of the botched rollout of the health care law, Williams says he couldn't help but notice - Landrieu was just trying to save her political skin in true Louisiana form.

WILLIAMS: You know, she was for him, but now it looks like she's kind of crawfishing, you know.

CHANG: What does that mean, crawfishing?

WILLIAMS: It means backing up. It's what it means, backing up.

CHANG: This far from Election Day, it's not clear how much backing up she can do, or even needs to do. She's already a three-term senator from a prominent political family. Obamacare came along just four years ago. Mary Landrieu's political history with the state goes back nearly nine times as far.

Ailsa Chang, NPR News.


MONTAGNE: You're listening to MORNING EDITION from NPR News.

Copyright © 2014 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.