Finding A More Nuanced View Of Poverty's 'Black Hole' Thirty-seven percent of New Yorkers faced severe material hardship last year, but the city's official poverty rate is only 21 percent. Researchers are trying to find a better way to measure poverty.
NPR logo

Finding A More Nuanced View Of Poverty's 'Black Hole'

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Finding A More Nuanced View Of Poverty's 'Black Hole'

Finding A More Nuanced View Of Poverty's 'Black Hole'

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


And let's go next to New York, where researchers are looking for a better way to measure poverty. It is not so easy to say just who is poor and who is not and it matters a lot because official definitions of poverty shape economic policies, tax credits, subsidies and much more.


The federal government bases poverty on a family's income, which most researchers say gives an incomplete snapshot. The researchers in New York have been gathering a lot more information than that, hoping for a more comprehensive picture. Today they have some initial results, as NPR's Pam Fassler reports.

PAM FESSLER, BYLINE: When I talk to low income people for stories, I often ask what poverty means to them. Frequently the answer involves more than a lack of money, something much more intangible.

ANNE VALDEZ: Like being stuck in a black hole.

FESSLER: That's Anne Valdez, who is 47, unemployed, trying to raise a teenage son in Coney Island, New York.

VALDEZ: Poverty is like literally being held back from enjoying life, almost to the point of not being able to breathe.

FESSLER: Now researchers from Columbia University and the Robin Hood Foundation, an anti-poverty group, are trying to get a more nuanced picture of what it means to be poor and struggling. They're following 2,300 New York City families, asking detailed questions over two years about their finances, their hardships, and their response.

MICHAEL WEINSTEIN: So we see that you were unemployed in January of last year. What did you do about it?

FESSLER: Michael Weinstein of the Robin Hood Foundation says one thing they're trying to learn is which programs work and which ones don't.

WEINSTEIN: Did you seek job training? If you sought job training, did you learn a skill? Were you able to translate that skill into a job? Were you able to keep that job? Those are kinds of questions that have to do with how things evolve over time.

FESSLER: And information that many current surveys don't provide. Families aren't just being asked about their income, but about whether they face what researchers call material hardship. Did they have trouble paying their rent? Did they lose their home or apartment? Did they run out of money for food, or put off going to the doctor?

WEINSTEIN: These are severe problems, and what's startling about the results of this survey is the percentage of families who suffer those problems, even though they are not technically poor.

FESSLER: In fact, an initial report out today finds that 37 percent of New Yorkers faced a severe material hardship over the past year, even though the city's official poverty rate is 21 percent. Even more striking is that many people with incomes well above the poverty line also face such hardships. Chris Wimer of Columbia University says there are many possible explanations.

CHRIS WIMER: Mental health issues, it could be excessive debt. So if a large portion of people's incomes is being used to service, you know, past medical debts, credit card debts, student loans, things like that, that may leave less room in the budget, ultimately.

FESSLER: So another thing they're asking is whether people have enough money set aside for an emergency, like a broken-down car. Wimer hopes their findings will help inform the national debate over how best to help the poor. Scott Winship, a fellow at the conservative-leaning Manhattan Institute, thinks it might. He says the problem of poverty is far more complex than it's often portrayed.

SCOTT WINSHIP: The full test of how adequate our anti-poverty policy is can't simply be, have we moved people above a line? Or by cutting this program or that program, are we moving more people below the line?

FESSLER: The real test is finding a way to help people like Anne Valdez get out of that black hole. Pam Fessler, NPR News.

Copyright © 2014 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.