To Make Bread, Watch The Dough, Not The Recipe : The Salt One man's quest for the perfect loaf took him to Paris, Berlin, California and Kansas. What he learned can't easily be captured in words. It's a feeling in your fingers that comes from experience.
NPR logo

To Make Bread, Watch The Dough, Not The Recipe

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
To Make Bread, Watch The Dough, Not The Recipe

To Make Bread, Watch The Dough, Not The Recipe

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


The art of baking bread at home barely survived the 20th century. Whether for lack of time or skill, few Americans bake their own bread anymore. Well, you can almost smell the nostalgia in a new book about breadmaking, which suggests the secret to success can't be captured in a recipe. NPR's Dan Charles needed to investigate.

DAN CHARLES, BYLINE: Samuel Fromartz makes his living as a writer. And he works at home on a quiet street near the Capitol building in Washington, D.C.



CHARLES: Your newspapers are piling up.

FROMARTZ: Yeah, I've been a little busy lately (laughter).

CHARLES: Not too busy to make bread, though. He usually does it a few times each week. It doesn't really take a lot of time, he says. In the evenings, he'll mix the dough and put it in the refrigerator to rise slowly overnight. The next day, when he needs a break from the computer, he'll go downstairs to the kitchen and make the loaves.

FROMARTZ: What takes time is the rising. But you're not doing anything while it's rising. So I go back to work.

CHARLES: He started doing this about 20 years ago just because he couldn't find bread that he liked. Then he got a little obsessive, making all kinds of loaves. He struggled for years to make a good baguette.

FROMARTZ: I finally decided, after several years, that it was impossible to make a decent baguette at home.

CHARLES: But then he landed a magazine assignment: go work in a bakery in Paris and write about it. That led to more bakery pilgrimages to Berlin and San Francisco and eventually to Fromartz's new book, "In Search Of The Perfect Loaf." Fromartz confesses, at first, these trips were a little disappointing.

FROMARTZ: I was traveling thousands of miles to work with bakers. And if you've ever spent time with bakers, you'll know that they are pretty introverted. They don't make a really great interview if you're a journalist. They're the kind of people who like to work in the middle of the night listening to loud music.

CHARLES: He wasn't getting great stories or colorful quotes. Some of these bakers, in fact, barely spoke English. So Fromartz adjusted his expectations.

FROMARTZ: What I decided was if I could learn one thing from any baker, the trip would be worth it.

CHARLES: And he did learn. But exactly what he learned is hard to put in a recipe. He saw how the bakers monitored their dough - the baguette maker in Paris, for instance.

FROMARTZ: He just would look at the dough and say, yeah, needs a little bit more water. Or the loaves would be rising, and to me, they would look like the baguettes were, like, really ready to go in the oven. And he looked down, and he said, five minutes.

CHARLES: He was seeing something that Fromartz couldn't. But gradually, Fromartz started to see it, too. And this is the thing that about breadmaking, Fromartz says, it's not completely predictable. Each batch of dough will behave a little bit differently because the living creatures in it - the yeast or the microbes in your sourdough starter - they react to the temperature and humidity in your kitchen or what brand of flour you're using. So when it comes to the key decisions, like when to shape the dough into a loaf or put it in the oven, you have to rely on your senses.

FROMARTZ: Your eyes, you know, looking at the dough, feeling it with your fingers. Just kind of knowing, I think, based on past experience 'cause you've made this loaf a thousand times, what the dough should look like.

CHARLES: But what's it supposed to look like? I ask him, try to describe it.

FROMARTZ: It should - I (laughter) I hesitate to say this, but it should kind of look alive. It shouldn't look like a stiff ball. It should look like it's kind of wanting to continue growing.

CHARLES: Right now, we're looking at a ball of dough. Samuel Fromartz seems a little skeptical.

FROMARTZ: I would actually prefer it if it had risen a little bit more. But it'll still make a decent loaf.

CHARLES: We decide to make a couple of baguettes, also a simple, round loaf.

FROMARTZ: And I'll just, like, flop it down a few times. And then I just fold into the middle to stretch the exterior skin but not compress the interior.

CHARLES: Fromartz works quickly, shaping the dough. He makes it look easy. The knowledge of how to do this is in his fingers. A few hours later, the loaves are done.

FROMARTZ: You know, I think it worked out. They look like you want to eat them, don't they?

CHARLES: They do. Let's eat them.


CHARLES: To me, those loaves seemed just perfect. Dan Charles, NPR News.

Copyright © 2014 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.