Doctor Shortage Looming? Maybe Not : Shots - Health News Physicians have been warning for years about a coming shortage of primary care doctors. But others say primary care teams that include other types of health workers might fill the gap better.

Doctor Shortage Looming? Maybe Not

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Medical schools hold a ceremony each year. First-year students get to wear their white coats for the very first time.


UNIDENTIFIED MAN #1: I'd like to welcome the entering class of 2018 to our School of Medicine.



That's the sound of a ceremony at Georgetown University. These students are assured of work when they graduate. Experts have said the U.S. needs tens of thousands of extra doctors for an aging population.

INSKEEP: At least, that's how it seems. Julie Rovner of Kaiser Health News has been asking if the doctor shortage is real.

JULIE ROVNER: The 196 new doctors-in-training at Georgetown this year have lots of company. U.S. medical schools are in the middle of 30 percent expansion that began in 2006. The Association of American Medical Colleges has led the charge, claiming the nation is approaching a serious shortage of doctors. Atul Grover is a physician and the group's chief public policy officer.

ATUL GROVER: We think the shortage is going to be close to 130,000 in the next 10 to 12 years.

ROVNER: It's not hard to see what leads to that prediction. Millions of people are getting insurance for the first time under the federal health law and 10,000 baby boomers are qualifying for Medicare every day.

GROVER: Essentially doubling of the number of people over the age of 65 within the course of a couple of decades. They're driving the demand for services.

ROVNER: The problem isn't just absolute numbers of doctors. Andrew Bazemore, a family physician who studies health workforce issues, says who those physicians are is important, too.

ANDREW BAZEMORE: And that means by their race and ethnicity, by their age, by their gender, by their backgrounds, do they actually look like and reflect the populations that they're going to serve?

ROVNER: There is agreement that the U.S. needs more people to provide primary care services, but they don't necessarily all have to be doctors, says health economist Gail Wilensky.

GAIL WILENSKY: There are a lot of primary care services that can be provided by a lot of people other than primary care doctors.

ROVNER: That includes physician assistants, nurse practitioners, even pharmacists and social workers working together in teams. Teams are thought to provide more cost-effective care, and says Wilensky, more non-physician health practitioners might lessen the need for more primary care doctors.

WILENSKY: What will we allow nurses to do - work up to limits of their training? What will we allow pharmacists to do? Those together will determine how many physicians would be useful to have around.

ROVNER: And all those studies predicting a doctor shortage, Wilensky says similar studies over the past 50 years predicting future physician supply needs have been laughably wrong.

WILENSKY: We haven't even been directionally correct sometimes, which is, we thought we were going into a surplus and we ended up with a shortage, or vice versa.

ROVNER: Even so medical school lobbyist Atul Grover said in a recent C-SPAN interview, it's better for society to err on the side that the shortage is real.

GROVER: We don't think that we should put patients at risk by saying, let's not train enough doctors just in case everything lines up perfectly and we don't need them.

ROVNER: But Wilensky, like many other health economists, scoffs at the idea of letting someone train as a doctor just in case.

WILENSKY: Are you really serious? You're talking about somebody who is potentially 12 to 15 years post-high school to invest in a skill set that we're not sure we're going to need.

ROVNER: And the potential price is more than just the time and expense for the individual doctors. Fitzhugh Mullan, a family physician and professor at George Washington University, says every new doctor adds cost to the health care system.

FITZHUGH MULLAN: Because training another doctor isn't cheap. It isn't cheap for the individual doing the training, it isn't cheap for the institution providing the education and ultimately, it isn't cheap for the health system because the more doctors we have, the more activity there will be.

ROVNER: There's still more to the debate over the doctor shortage. How much of the problem is due to the geographic distribution of doctors and the inability to get doctors to move to rural and more remote places? How much is due to a payment system that rewards quantity over quality and how much to the spiraling cost of medical education that pushes doctors away from lower-cost primary care?

The answers will have a profound impact not just on America's doctors, but America's patients as well.

For NPR News I'm Julie Rovner.

Copyright © 2014 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.