After Nazi Plunder, A Quest To Bring Home The 'Woman In Gold' A new movie tells the true story of Maria Altmann, who fought her way to the U.S. Supreme Court to force the Austrian government to return a painting of her aunt.

After Nazi Plunder, A Quest To Bring Home The 'Woman In Gold'

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


This week, the movie "Woman In Gold" opens, a film about one of the great battles in art history. The story begins with the Nazi takeover of Austria in 1938. Newlyweds Maria Altmann and her husband are wealthy Jews, desperately fleeing for their lives and leaving her family's famous artworks behind. That's where stars Helen Mirren and Ryan Reynolds come in, playing the much older Maria and her young lawyer fighting to get the art back from the Austrian government. NPR legal affairs correspondent Nina Totenberg covered that real life, modern-day legal battle.

NINA TOTENBERG, BYLINE: Maria Altmann was 88 when I first met her by phone in 2004. Would it be possible to call back in a few minutes, she asked. I'm feeling a little dizzy and would like a cup of coffee to revive myself. Of course, I said, imagining Mrs. Altmann as a somewhat frail grandmother. Old she was, but frail she was not. Against all odds, she had fought her way to the U.S. Supreme Court in her quest to force the Austrian government to give back the painting of her aunt, Adele Bloch-Bauer. Painted by Gustav Klimt in 1907, the enormous, shimmering gold and oil on canvas was one of six Klimt paintings confiscated by the Nazis from the Bloch-Bauer home. After the war, the work showed up in Austria's federal art museum, the Galerie Belvedere. The Austrian government claimed the paintings had been willed to the government, a claim that would later be found to be fraudulent. But even after the falsehood was finally exposed in 1998, it was a long road to getting the paintings back, especially the portrait of Altmann's aunt, the "Woman In Gold." This scene from the new movie says it all.


DANIEL BRUHL: (As character) Listen, she is the Mona Lisa of Austria. Do you think they will just let her go?

TOTENBERG: The answer to that question was no. The Austrian government fought with everything it had to keep the painting. And Mrs. Altmann fought back with equal ferocity. Here is the real Maria Altmann talking to me in 2004.


MARIA ALTMANN: I grew up with those paintings.

TOTENBERG: Altmann said the golden portrait of her aunt and five other Klimt paintings hung in her aunt and Uncle Ferdinand's palatial home throughout her childhood. Her aunt, Adele, the subject of the portrait, was just 43 when she died in 1925. Thirteen years later, Ferdinand would flee Austria just weeks before the Anschluss, the union with Hitler's Germany. Everything was left behind and plundered by top Nazis, such as Hermann Goering. Aunt Adele's diamond necklace, passed on to Maria upon her marriage, reportedly ended up decorating the neck of Goering's wife. And of course, the Klimt paintings were seized, too, only to reappear after the war in the Galerie Belvedere. It took a half century and the opening of Austrian government archives to expose the real story, as Maria Altmann put it in our 2004 interview.


ALTMANN: They are basing this on a lie. These paintings are not theirs. These paintings belong to us.

TOTENBERG: It turned out Aunt Adele's will did not bequeath the paintings to the Austrian Galerie. Her will asked that her husband, Ferdinand, donate the Klimts to the museum upon his death. The language of the will was framed as a request and was called not binding because Ferdinand had paid for the paintings. They were his. They weren't hers to give away even if she wanted to. And the Austrian museum knew that. What's more, Ferdinand, who died impoverished in Switzerland at the end of the war, made a will of his own, leaving all his property to his nephews and nieces. Maria was the only one still alive in 1998 when a series of investigative articles in the Austrian press revealed the paintings true ownership. In our 2004 interview, she furiously stated one additional and obvious fact. Adele would never have wanted her portrait given to the Austrian Galerie had she known the history that would unfold after her death in 1925.


ALTMANN: She had no idea. She would have never requested her husband even in a dream to leave these to the gallery after a number of her friends were murdered, committed suicide. I mean, it is totally incomprehensible that such a thing would have happened.

TOTENBERG: Maria could not have won the battle to recover the paintings alone, though. Her legal spear carrier was a 32-year-old legal nobody named Randol Schoenberg, the grandson of Austrian composer Arnold Schoenberg, and a family friend. He was a young lawyer and as re-enacted in the movie, she needed help.


HELEN MIRREN: (As Maria Altmann) I need advice from someone I can trust. Here she is, my aunt.

RYAN REYNOLDS: (As Randol Schoenberg) That's quite a painting.

MIRREN: (As Maria Altmann) She was taken off the walls of our home by the Nazis. Since then, she's been hanging in Vienna.

REYNOLDS: (As Randol Schoenberg) And now you'd like to be reunited.

TOTENBERG: Few thought the duo would prevail when the case got to the U.S. Supreme Court, especially when the George W. Bush administration sided with the government of Austria, saying Mrs. Altmann could not sue in the U.S. But prevail they did. The win, however, left them with many more legal mountains to climb, namely, a trial that, even if they won, would be followed by long appeals. Indeed, Mrs. Altmann often feared that the Austrian government was just waiting for her to die. Still, after the Supreme Court victory, she was characteristically a realist.


ALTMANN: I have a feeling that they will now come to their senses. They couldn't let it come to a trial because it would bring too much dirt out against the Austrians.

TOTENBERG: When I interviewed her, she was frankly embarrassed by the price tags being mentioned for the portrait of her aunt. She'd offered to let the Austrian government keep the painting originally if they admitted it had been stolen. They weren't interested. But now, she said, that offer was off the table. She didn't want the painting of her aunt or the other Klimts to remain in Austria. She wanted them back in the country where she had been a citizen for over 60 years, the United States.


ALTMANN: This is strictly a question of justice.


MIRREN: (As Maria Altmann) Because people forget, you see, especially the young. And then, of course, there's justice.

TOTENBERG: In the end, Austria did want to avoid a trial and agreed to arbitration in Austria. The result was the return of all the Klimt paintings. Jewish philanthropist Ronald Lauder bought the "Woman In Gold" portrait for $135 million to display at his museum in New York, the Neue Galerie. The other Klimt paintings sold for another $192 million.

Mrs. Altmann died in 2011 at the age of 94. As for the golden portrait of her aunt, eventually, I went to see it in New York. My husband and I just stood there transfixed by its beauty. I didn't want to leave. Nina Totenberg, NPR News, Washington.


You hear Nina on MORNING EDITION from NPR News. I'm Steve Inskeep.

MONTAGNE: And I'm Renee Montagne.

Copyright © 2015 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.