Critics Lash Out At Chinese Scientists Who Edited DNA In Human Embryos : Shots - Health News By editing the genes in embryos in the lab, Chinese scientists showed that it's possible to change hereditary traits that cause a blood disorder. But the work also created unintended mutations.

Critics Lash Out At Chinese Scientists Who Edited DNA In Human Embryos

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


Scientists in China face accusations that they crossed an ethical line. That's because of what they did with human embryos. The scientists claim to have edited the DNA in human embryos. The reason was to see if they could prevent future health problems. NPR health correspondent Rob Stein has been following the story. He's in our studios. Rob, good morning.

ROB STEIN, BYLINE: Good morning.

INSKEEP: So what exactly did they do?

STEIN: Yeah, Steve, this is a group of scientists at Sun Yat-sen University in Guangzhou - that's in southern China. And they used a new technique for editing DNA for doing genetic engineering to try to fix a gene that causes a blood disorder that can be fatal sometimes called beta-thalassemia.

INSKEEP: OK - Sounds like a well-intentioned idea. What's wrong with it?

STEIN: Well, this is hugely controversial, and here's why. You know, scientists have been able to manipulate DNA to do genetic engineer for a long time now. But there's always been one thing that's been considered taboo, off-limits. And that's changing the DNA inside a human sperm, a human egg or a human embryo. And the reason is if you do that, whatever change you make can be passed down for generations. And there are lots of reasons not to do that. One is you can make some kind of mistake. You could end up...

INSKEEP: Unintended consequences, sure.

STEIN: Exactly. And you end up creating a new disease that would then be passed down for generations. And the other concern is sort of the bigger societal concern that this sort of thing could be sort of a slippery slope towards all kinds of, like, "Brave New World" kinds of things, including making designer babies, where parents can pick the traits of their children to be smarter or taller or better athletes and, you know, essentially, genetically engineering the human race.

INSKEEP: Yeah, changing what it means to be human. Although the scientists say they were just trying to deal with this medical issue. Did their effort actually work?

STEIN: Well, they say they did this because there's this new technique that I mentioned. It's a new technique. It's called CRISPR, which makes it much easier to do very precise changes in human DNA. And scientists are really excited about this because it could lead to all sorts of good things and ways to prevent human diseases from occurring. And the scientists say, you know, if we're going to eve try to do that, we need to try it and see if it works.

And so, as I said, they tried to fix a gene called the HBB gene which causes that blood disease I mentioned earlier. And, you know, they did this on embryos that weren't viable, meaning that if you ever tried to put them inside of a woman's womb, they wouldn't survive. And that was to try to address some of these ethical issues that I mentioned earlier. And they tried it on 86 embryos. And essentially, it worked but not really very well. Some of the embryos didn't survive. They did edit some of the DNA in some of the embryos. But even there, it also created mutations elsewhere in the DNA that they didn't intend to create. So basically, it didn't work very well.

INSKEEP: So, Rob Stein, as I'm listening to this, I'm thinking of the very strong reaction many people have to genetically modified plants - GMOs - eating them, using them in any way. There must be a very strong reaction to the idea of genetically modified people.

STEIN: Oh, yeah, absolutely. I mean, this is something that people have been worried about for generations, for decades. And, you know, there's been lots of thought and debate about doing this sort of thing. And in fact, there've been rumors that this might've happened for several weeks now. So several weeks ago, several prominent groups of scientists issued basically public appeals to the scientific community worldwide not to do this. They said, look, we're nowhere close to being ready to try this. It's not safe. We don't know if it's going to work. And that included even the researcher who developed this technique I mentioned, CRISPR. She's concerned about moving ahead too quickly.

But there's no way to really enforce that kind of moratorium. And this report essentially confirms their worst fears. So I've been in touch with some of those scientists over the last 12 hours or so. And they're basically saying, look, you know, this is exactly what we've been worried about. And this is just - it gives us another reason why we should stop doing this kind of research until we've really debated these issues a lot more thoroughly and know that this is safe.

INSKEEP: Not the end of the story. Rob Stein, thanks very much.

STEIN: Oh, sure. Nice to be here.

INSKEEP: That's NPR's Rob Stein.

Copyright © 2015 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.