New Power Plant Rules Likely To Start Slow-Burning Debate, Legal Action A huge legal battle is coming over the White House plan to address climate change with additional power plant regulations. The coal industry has the most to lose, and plans to take the EPA to court.
NPR logo

New Power Plant Rules Likely To Start Slow-Burning Debate, Legal Action

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
New Power Plant Rules Likely To Start Slow-Burning Debate, Legal Action


And now to another debate in Washington over President Obama's plan to address climate change. Under the plan, the EPA is putting in place new limits on greenhouse gas emissions from power plants. Critics argue this plan is on shaky legal ground and that consumers will bear some of the brunt. Let's dig into the positions on both sides with NPR's Jeff Brady.

JEFF BRADY, BYLINE: In announcing what the White House calls its Clean Power Plan, President Obama predicted some of the arguments his critics are making.

BARACK OBAMA: They will claim that this plan will cost you money, even though this plan, the analysis shows, will ultimately save the average American nearly $85 a year on their energy bills.

BRADY: And coal company Murray Energy predicts the regulations will dramatically raise the cost of electricity. The company says it will challenge the regulations in court. Critics already were pretty worked up over a draft plan released last year. When they learned the final regulations released Monday are even tougher, that really upset them. Here's West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey.


PATRICK MORRISEY: The administration has doubled down on its absolute illegal attempt to transform the EPA from an environmental regulator to a central energy planning authority.

BRADY: The administration counters that kind of talk with assurances the states can develop their own plans for complying with the new carbon limits. But that doesn't address something Morrisey and some other state officials see as their opportunity to overturn these regulations.


MORRISEY: We believe that this proposal is fundamentally and patently illegal.

BRADY: The EPA is relying on the Clean Air Act for its authority to draft the regulations. Attorney General Morrisey says one thing that makes the new regulations illegal is that power plants already are subject to one section of the Clean Air Act. Now the EPA wants to regulate them under another section, too. And he says that's not allowed. But Jody Freeman thinks the EPA will prevail on that point. She's a professor at Harvard Law School and former White House counselor for Energy and Climate Change in the Obama administration. She was very familiar with the EPA's draft regulations and has been looking over the new document for changes.

JODY FREEMAN: The final version of the plan is far more solid, far more legally defensible than the draft was.

BRADY: One example Freeman points to, the draft version set emission targets for entire states instead of specific polluters, and that was a weakness critics could've exploited in court.

FREEMAN: Now what EPA has done is put the regulatory burden directly on the power plants themselves to cut their pollution. And that's just much more direct, and it aligns better with the Clean Air Act.

BRADY: Freeman says the EPA's new regulations are ambitious. She says get ready for a legal ground war, one that she predicts will last the next couple of years and end up in the Supreme Court. A more immediate question is whether a judge will issue a stay, essentially put the regulations on hold while both sides duke it out in court. Jeff Brady, NPR News.

Copyright © 2015 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.