Hunger Strike Raises Debate About Force-Feeding In Israeli Prisons : Parallels After a Palestinian prisoner's hunger strike, Israel's parliament passed a law permitting the force-feeding of prisoners to keep them alive, but doctors made it clear they wouldn't participate
NPR logo

Hunger Strike Raises Debate About Force-Feeding In Israeli Prisons

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Hunger Strike Raises Debate About Force-Feeding In Israeli Prisons

Hunger Strike Raises Debate About Force-Feeding In Israeli Prisons

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


A Palestinian man in Israeli custody came close to starving to death this week. Mohammad Allan had refused food for two months to protest being held without charges. During his hunger strike, Israel passed a law permitting the force-feeding of prisoners in order to keep them alive. Israeli doctors fought back. NPR's Emily Harris reports.

EMILY HARRIS, BYLINE: We'll get to the man who almost starved to death in a minute, but first, meet Palestinian Ismat Mansour. He's a repeat hunger-striker. He ate just salt and water for at least three weeks, four separate times, when he was in prison. Free now, he was incarcerated two decades for helping kill an Israeli. Hunger strikes, he says, hurt.

ISMAT MANSOUR: (Through interpreter) It is the worst feeling in your body, your mind, your whole being. When I didn't eat for 28 days, I felt weak. I craved food. I couldn't remember things.

HARRIS: He says Israeli doctors kept watch over him and other hunger-striking prisoners.

MANSOUR: (Through interpreter) A doctor came and took blood pressure and weight and registered that every day. They would tell us if we didn't eat, we might die. But we knew they were from the prison authority, so we didn't trust them.

HARRIS: Mansour participated in hunger strikes with groups of Palestinian prisoners. Their aims were to improve life in Israeli custody. The Palestinian man who recently came close to death was in a different situation. Suspected of militant ties, Mohammad Allan had been detained but not charged for eight months when he began to refuse food. Six weeks into his fast, Israel's parliament passed a law permitting the state to force-feed prisoners on hunger strike. But doctors made it clear they would not cooperate.

YOEL DONSHIN: It's like rape. I mean, you will ask a physician to rape the patient for treatment or something like this. This is unacceptable.

HARRIS: Israeli doctor Yoel Donshin is a retired anesthesiologist and a member of Physicians for Human Rights. He believes Israeli politicians who favor force-feeding aren't concerned about the prisoners.

DONSHIN: They do not care for the welfare of the prisoners. They just want them not to become a symbol or martyr. So keep them alive. Keep them alive by all means.

HARRIS: As Allan grew weaker, Palestinian protests grew. Israeli authorities feared his death could trigger street violence. But amid the turbulent public debate, one lawmaker who had voted against allowing force-feeding, said on Israeli radio he changed his mind. Yaakov Peri also used to head Israel's internal security.

YAAKOV PERI: (Through interpreter) The only solution is that he be fed. I was against the force-feeding bill, but the alternative is an end to his life. There are times when the state of Israel has to make a decision. And if we need to force-feed him, we will have to force-feed him.

HARRIS: It turned out Mohammad Allan didn't need to be force-fed. Israel's Supreme Court temporarily suspended his detention, and he agreed to take nutrients. Israel's public security minister opposed that court ruling. He warned that more Palestinian prisoners will now go on extreme hunger strikes. And on his Facebook page, he criticized the doctor who heads the Israeli Medical Association for telling physicians to ignore the new Israeli law. That doctor, Leonid Idleman, says he did nothing wrong.

LEONID IDLEMAN: It's not breaking the law because there is no law in Israel to force doctors to use the treatment the doctors don't believe that should be used.

HARRIS: Under Israel's force-feeding law, a judge can allow but not order a doctor to participate. Israel's not the only place force-feeding is an issue. The U.S. military continues to force-feed hunger-strikers held at Guantanamo Bay. In Israel, Leonid Idleman and other physicians say they would honor a patient's wishes to refuse food but would step in to save his life if he were unconscious. Idleman says that would suit Mohammad Allan, who wanted a trial or freedom, not death.

IDLEMAN: Because after he was resuscitated, he regained his conscious, and he didn't regret that he was resuscitated.

HARRIS: Mohammad Allan ended his hunger strike after the Israeli court ruling. The force-feeding law remains on the books, awaiting a future case and a future debate with Israel's doctors. Emily Harris, NPR News, Jerusalem.

Copyright © 2015 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.