Texas Abortion Law Tested By Supreme Court At issue is whether a Texas law requiring clinics to meet surgical-center standards is aimed at safeguarding women's health or unconstitutionally limiting a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy.


Supreme Court Tests Texas' New Restrictions On Abortion

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/468656213/468851126" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


The Supreme Court floats in the background of most presidential elections but not this one. And the reason why the High Court is front and center will be clear today when eight, rather than nine justices, hear arguments in a case involving abortion. At issue is whether a Texas law imposes restrictions that unconstitutionally limit a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy. If upheld, the Texas law could lead to a dramatic cut back on abortion rights across the country. NPR legal affairs correspondent Nina Totenberg reports.


UNIDENTIFIED PROTESTER: God commands you to not murder your baby. God hates the hands that shed innocent blood.

NINA TOTENBERG, BYLINE: At the Fort Worth clinic, the protesters are out early in the morning - and so are the patients, some of whom have traveled long distances by car and bus to get here.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #1: I figured there'd be another clinic in my city and come to find out there wasn't.

TOTENBERG: This woman took a day off and drove nearly 300 miles round-trip to get an abortion. There was an abortion clinic in her home city. But it closed on the day the new Texas law, known as HB2, went into effect in 2014. Indeed, before the law was enacted, there were 41 abortion clinics in the state. Today, there are 19. And if both of the provisions at issue in today's case are upheld, at least 10 of those 19 would close, including this clinic in Fort Worth. As passionate as abortion rights advocates are about this case, so too are abortion opponents, including one of the co-authors of HB2, Jason Isaac, who says his mother was born as the result of a rape in 1944.

JASON ISAAC: I don't believe that I would be here today conducting this interview if Roe v. Wade were effect - in effect in 1944.

TOTENBERG: The new Texas law requires all abortions to be done in ambulatory surgical centers that are mini hospitals with wide corridors, large operating rooms and an advanced air conditioning system among other requirements. A second provision requires any doctor performing an abortion to have admitting privileges at a hospital within 30 miles of the clinic. Again, Mr. Isaac.

ISAAC: To me, that seems like good, common sense legislation.

TOTENBERG: Virtually the entire established medical profession in Texas and nationally disagrees. The American Medical Association and other major medical groups have joined the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists in telling the justices that these provisions are unnecessary. They're harmful to women's health and safety, expensive and cause delays that sometimes push abortions into the second trimester. Texas Solicitor General Scott Keller will tell the justices today that 10 women a week visit emergency rooms for complications from abortion, both surgical and by pill, and that the ambulatory surgical center standards are necessary for dealing with more acute emergencies.

SCOTT KELLER: Ensuring that EMT's can have access to the facilities, that there are - there's not a maze of hallways.

TOTENBERG: At the Fort Worth clinic, hallways are only about half the 8-foot width of the state law requirement. But as Dr. Bhavik Kumar points out, wide enough for a stretcher.

BHAVIK KUMAR: They would come in through this door. Both the procedure rooms would be directly accessible by anybody.

TOTENBERG: The doctor says that in his year at the clinic, he's had no emergencies requiring outside medical help.

KUMAR: It's a simple procedure, about five to eight minutes depending on how far along they are.

TOTENBERG: Dr. Kumar notes that there's no general anesthesia as there is for colonoscopies, liposuction and other procedures that are not so strictly regulated in Texas.

HAL LAWRENCE: Actually, it's much safer than a colonoscopy.

TOTENBERG: Dr. Hal Lawrence is CEO of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, ACOG.

LAWRENCE: The instance of a serious complication requiring hospitalization for abortion is incredibly low.

TOTENBERG: Indeed, one study published in the American Journal of Public Health found that major complications from first trimester surgical abortions occur one-twentieth of 1 percent of the time. The state's Keller replies that when there are serious complications however, it's important to have a physician with hospital admitting privileges nearby the clinic.

KELLER: Everyone admits that there can be significant health consequences from those complications.

TOTENBERG: But the brief filed by major medical associations contends that in today's medical world, doctors are increasingly giving up hospital privileges to doctors hired by the hospital. And, says ACOG's Dr. Lawrence, if an abortion patient does go to the hospital with some sort of complication...

LAWRENCE: ...There are obviously emergency room physicians there and OBGYN's at those hospitals that can help.

TOTENBERG: Lawyer Stephanie Toti will tell the Supreme Court today that if the admitting privileges and ambulatory surgical center requirements truly offered a health benefit, they would apply across the board to all similar, and indeed more dangerous, outpatient procedures.

STEPHANIE TOTI: But the fact that Texas has singled out abortion by itself for the imposition of these requirements shows that their true purpose isn't to improve patient health and safety. It's just to burden abortion.

TOTENBERG: The Supreme Court has allowed states to regulate abortion differently from other procedures. But it said states may not impose an undue burden on a woman's right to terminate a pregnancy. Texas argues there is no undue burden here. Scott Keller maintains that even if many more clinics are forced to close...

KELLER: ...Every metropolitan area in Texas that has a clinic today will still have one.

TOTENBERG: Clinic defenders counter that fast expanses of this second-largest state in the country would be uncovered, making for long waits at the existing clinics. That's borne out by the women we met at the Fort Worth clinic who asked not to be identified for fear of harassment. This woman raced to the clinic when a cancellation allowed her to avoid a one month wait.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #2: It'd be a very devastating thing for women not to be able to make their own choice and have to wait a month and be even further along to not be able to do this.

TOTENBERG: Another woman drove 200 miles round-trip with her husband to get here because the abortion clinics that were near her town had closed, and the birth of her first child, she says, nearly killed her.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #3: I had a severe complication in the birth process, and the doctor advised me not to have any more. So here we are.

TOTENBERG: Texas Statehouse member Isaac replies that women who live two or 300 miles from the nearest clinic should acknowledge that reality.

ISAAC: Well, hopefully they'll be more preventative.

TOTENBERG: You mean not get pregnant.

ISAAC: Not get pregnant yes, and realize that hey, that might still be an option legally, but now I live 300 miles away from the nearest place. I should probably be more careful.

TOTENBERG: Despite the death of Justice Antonin Scalia last month, Justice Anthony Kennedy remains the likely swing vote in this case. If he votes to strike down the Texas law, there would be at least a 5 to 3 majority for that outcome. But if he votes to uphold the law, the court would likely be tied. And the Texas abortion law would remain in place, at least for now. Nina Totenberg, NPR news, Washington.

[POST-BROADCAST CORRECTION: An earlier version of this transcript incorrectly attributed two quotes. It was Texas State Rep. Jason Isaac who said that if clinics that perform abortions are farther away from their homes, women might be "more preventative." He also said that women might not "get pregnant ... and realize that, 'hey, that might still be an option legally, but now I live 300 miles away from the nearest place. I should probably be more careful.'"]

Copyright © 2016 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.