To Save Their Water Supply, Colorado Farmers Taxed Themselves : The Salt The recent drought in the West forced people to take a hard look at how they use water. In Colorado, some farmers tried an experiment: make their water more expensive without hurting business.

To Save Their Water Supply, Colorado Farmers Taxed Themselves

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript


The Western United States is just starting to recover from a prolonged drought which forced residents to take a hard look at how they use water. In Southern Colorado, farmers are trying a bold experiment to do their part to conserve water. From member station KUNC, Luke Runyon reports.

LUKE RUNYON, BYLINE: Colorado's San Luis Valley is a desperately dry stretch of land, about the same size as New Jersey.

DOUG MESSICK: So you can see here we got our water meter.

RUNYON: Doug Messick’s potato farm sits in the middle of that valley. His fields are full of russets, the kind you'd use for a loaded baked potato. Above the plants, dozens of nozzles spray down perfect little water droplets. It's what keeps the fields green. Without irrigation, this valley is a desert. Messick pumps water from a shallow aquifer under our feet. Today, there's enough to keep it running, but when that epic drought started 16 years ago...

MESSICK: The aquifer was declining, but nobody really started noticing until they started sucking air instead of water back in the early 2000s.

RUNYON: Suddenly, the valley's seemingly endless supply of groundwater was gone. Neighbors argued about who was to blame. Farmers panicked. State regulators threatened to swoop in with harsh restrictions. Cleave Simpson runs the Rio Grande Water Conservation District.

CLEAVE SIMPSON: We couldn't sit back and just pump to the bottom of the aquifer.

RUNYON: The lack of water would set off this horrible domino effect, Simpson says. Without water, you can't have farms. And without farms, the nearby towns suffer.

SIMPSON: If we don't act, we might not be here as early as the next 10 years. So it's not like something that's going to happen a hundred years from now.

RUNYON: For farmers, the options were simple - keep pumping until everyone's water ran out or cut back. After years of court cases and infighting, Simpson says the farmers made a painful decision. They agreed that to save their livelihoods, everyone had to pay more for water.

SIMPSON: It incentivizes conservation efforts because it hits your pocketbook directly.

RUNYON: For six years now, farmers have been paying more every time they turn on their pump - three or four times more. That can be tens of thousands, even hundreds of thousands of dollars each year for water. This was the first time here in the U.S. that a group of farmers did something like this, voting to tax their water use. And no one really knew if it would work.

KELSEY CODY: We were able to determine that effectively, yes, they've been able to reduce their groundwater extraction pretty substantially.

RUNYON: Kelsey Cody is part of a University of Colorado research team that found farmers who had to pay cut their pumping by 30 percent and with an important side note - those same farms aren't closing up shop because of the high cost. Today, the aquifer in the San Luis Valley isn't quite recharged, but Cody says the initial results are promising.

CODY: Anywhere that there is groundwater, there's almost always going to be challenges in managing it because it's difficult to see. It's difficult to monitor. It's easy to think that it's everlasting.

MESSICK: Oh, look there - tubers.

RUNYON: Back at farmer Doug Messick's potato field, it's harvest time, which means a big payday for all his work.

MESSICK: So yeah, it seems stupid to actually tax yourselves and cost yourself more money. But the big picture is you stay in business and you keep your community whole. And everybody gives a little...

RUNYON: So that everybody can survive. For NPR News, I'm Luke Runyon in Colorado's San Luis Valley.

Copyright © 2017 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.