Dallas Man Exonerated After 27 Years in Prison James Lee Woodard walked out of a Texas prison last week after almost three decades behind bars. The state now agrees that Woodard was wrongfully convicted in 1981 of killing a girl he had been dating. Woodard is the 17th man from Dallas to be cleared by DNA evidence.
NPR logo

Dallas Man Exonerated After 27 Years in Prison

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/90172724/90180106" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Dallas Man Exonerated After 27 Years in Prison

Law

Dallas Man Exonerated After 27 Years in Prison

  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/90172724/90180106" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

STEVE INSKEEP, host:

James Lee Woodard walked out last week of a Texas prison after 27 years behind bars. The state agrees that Mr. Woodard was wrongfully convicted in 1981. He was convicted of killing a girl the he had been dating. And now he's part of a pattern.

Woodard is the 17th man from Dallas alone - the 17th - to be exonerated by DNA evidence, and nearly all those freed are African-Americans. As NPR's Wade Goodwyn reports, the district attorney's office is predicting that Woodard is not going to be the last inmate exonerated.

WADE GOODWYN: James Lee Woodard had been dating 21-year-old Beverly Ann Jones for seven months before she was raped and murdered. It was Christmastime 1980, and although the young woman had no idea, her time was running out.

Mr. JAMES LEE WOODARD: She told me that she was going to spend the weekend with her mother and take her mother some Christmas presents. She was sitting in the bathtub when I left.

GOODWYN: Woodard would never see Jones again. A few days later, Woodard was with his mother when word began racing around the neighborhood that Beverly Ann Jones had been found murdered down by the Trinity River. Woodard says he was stunned. He got in his car and drove around by himself for awhile before going back to his mother's house.

Mr. WOODARD: I was sitting on her couch. I wanted to see the news, and someone knocked on the door. It was the police.

GOODWYN: Woodard didn't think anything of it. He thought the cops wanted his input to help their investigation. He hopped in his car and went down to the station behind the officers. But once he arrived, he quickly discovered that he was becoming the police's prime suspect. The detective took Woodard aside.

Mr. WOODARD: He said, we really don't have nothing to tie you into it. It's your people who are saying you did it.

GOODWYN: Beverly Jones's stepfather told the police that on the night she was murdered, Woodard had come to his house looking for her. That identification, which the stepfather now concedes was incorrect, steered the police toward Woodard, and they slapped him into jail. But even at that point, Woodard was blinded by his innocence.

Mr. WOODARD: You know, I just wrote it off as, hey, you know, they're going to lock me up, I guess, until they really check it out.

GOODWYN: He had no idea how wrong he was. He was about to lose the next three decades of his life to prison. And the fact was, Woodard had pretty good reason not to worry - he had a solid, if somewhat embarrassing, alibi. Woodard was two-timing Jones, and the night she was murdered, Woodard was 30 miles away in Arlington, spending the night with his other girlfriend.

Not only that, but they were at the girl's aunt's house, and the aunt was there all night too. These two women told police that Woodard couldn't have murdered Jones because he was with them. But Woodard was an attractive suspect to the police. He was an ex-con because he'd been convicted of theft when he was a teenager.

Dallas District Attorney Craig Watkins says that back in the late '70s and '80s, good alibis didn't necessarily carry a lot of weight when those circumstances were present.

Mr. CRAIG WATKINS (Dallas District Attorney): Let's just go back during that time. The political climate was being tough on crime. And the success of the DAs - it was considered to be very successful if you had a very high conviction rate, you sent a lot of folks to prison.

GOODWYN: Watkins is Texas's first African-American district attorney and he says he saw plenty of prosecutorial abuse when he was on the other side as a defense attorney. Now that he's running the DA's office, he's completely changed the culture.

Watkins has demanded more money to investigate questionable convictions, and because of all the publicity, Dallas's tight-fisted county commissioners have reluctantly complied. When Watkins's investigators reviewed Woodard's case, they found blatant evidence of prosecutorial misconduct.

It turns out one witness had come forward and told police that he'd seen Beverly Ann Jones in the company of three other men the night she was raped and murdered. Not only that, but two of these men had been arrested and charged with raping other women since the Jones murder. And even though prosecutors are required by law to turn over exculpatory evidence to defense counsel, Watkins says the police department and the Dallas district attorney's office at the time maliciously kept the information from the jury.

Mr. WATKINS: It's ruining lives. Not only is it ruining defendants' lives, but the victim. Because if you just put someone in jail because it's easy, the person that actually committed the crime is still out there and still committing crime. I believe that the failures of the DAs have really added to the criminal problem we have in Texas.

GOODWYN: James Lee Woodard is the 17th man to be released using DNA evidence just from Dallas. The reason Dallas has had so many exonerations is because unlike every other major city in Texas, Dallas kept its DNA evidence instead of throwing it out.

Perhaps the most unsettling fact in all of this is that out of the 40 cases to have been reviewed so far, there have been 17 exonerations. That's an error rate of more than 40 percent. When asked how many more exonerations can be expected, the Dallas DA says a lot.

Mr. WATKINS: It's going to be more than dozens. It's going to be a lot more. I couldn't tell you an exact number. I think there's a large number of individuals that may have been convicted where there's no DNA, and then the real perpetrator is out there, and we have to figure out how to address that.

GOODWYN: What's new about this case is that James Lee Woodard is the first to be exonerated of murder. All the other men were convicted of rape. The district attorney very likely could have kept Woodard in prison by simply taking the position that even though the DNA proved Woodard hadn't been the one to rape Jones, that meant nothing to his murder conviction.

But the Dallas district attorney says he has no interest in keeping innocent men in prison, and he's investigating other questionable cases in cooperation with the Innocence Project of Texas. Jeff Blackburn is the chief counsel.

Mr. JEFF BLACKBURN (Innocence Project of Texas): The easy cases are over. Mr. Woodard's case is an example of what's really out there now. For every James Lee Woodard there is out there, there are 500 other guys exactly like him who just didn't have the good luck to be from a county where they preserved evidence. That doesn't make them any less innocent. It just makes the work to get them out and to prove their innocence that much harder.

GOODWYN: Blackburn has enlisted the help of students and professors from three Texas law schools and two universities to help with the labor-intensive process of combing through the case files. He says he has four more almost exactly like James Lee Woodard's already in line.

Blackburn believes the number of innocent men in Texas prisons convicted of rape and murder runs into the hundreds. But for one innocent man, life begins anew after 27 years of waiting.

Mr. WOODARD: Like an adventure. I mean there's so many different things to see, and I like people, and I like seeing different things and new things.

GOODWYN: James Lee Woodard doesn't know how a cell phone works, has no inkling of Macintosh versus PC, and probably he's neither bitter nor angry, and if you ask he will not agree that those years in prison were for naught.

Mr. WOODARD: Time is what you make of it. You're living no matter where you are. I think I came out pretty good. I think I won. I think I'm a winner.

GOODWYN: As the years went by, Woodard never gave up writing letters and writs to anybody who might help him prove his innocence. He couldn't get parole because he steadfastly refused to say he was sorry, even after one board member quietly took him aside and said they'd set him free if he would. He loves dogs and would still like to have a family, but believes most women are likely to see him as damaged goods.

But with an easy smile, fit and attractive at age 55, he could be wrong about that.

Wade Goodwyn, NPR News, Dallas.

(Soundbite of music)

INSKEEP: You can get a look at letters that James Lee Woodard sent as he tried to gain his release by going to NPR.org.

Copyright © 2008 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.